State Bar of Michigan
home member area contact us


ethics



 print this page


for members
SBM general information

member directory

admissions, ethics, and
   regulation


diversity & inclusion

justice initiatives

member services

practice management
   resource center


public policy resource
   center


publications and
   advertising


research and links

sections & committees


ethics for members
ethics developments
ethics opinions
TAON (trust accounts)


from the courts
opinion searching
virtual court


for the public
public resources
media resources


giving opportunities
a lawyer helps
access to justice
   campaign

Ethics Opinion

print this page

NOTE: Various references in this ethics opinion to portions of the Michigan Code of Judicial Conduct are no longer accurate due to amendments effective August 1, 2013. Click here to review language added to (which is underlined) and language stricken from (which is indicated by strikethrough) Canons 2, 4, 5, and 7.

JI-49

March 20, 1992

SYLLABUS

    If the purpose of the event is not fund-raising, a group of judges may hold a testimonial dinner in honor of a nonjudge, invite lawyers and judges to the event, and assess each attendee a pro rata share of the actual costs of the event.

    If the purpose of the event is fund-raising, a group of judges holding a testimonial dinner may solicit funds from attendees only if a nonjudge handles the solicitation and the funds, and only if the proceeds are allocated to a bona fide educational, religious, charitable, fraternal or civic organization.

    References: MCJC 5B, 6; JI-9, JI-33.

TEXT

A group of judges wishes to hold a testimonial dinner honoring a nonjudge, and asks:

  1. May judge and lawyer attendees to the event be asked to contribute to the cost of the dinner?
  2. If so, do ethics rules require the establishment of a separate account for the funds, or may the solicited funds be collected by the organizing judge?
  3. If the judge may collect the funds directly, must the funds be reported pursuant to MCJC 6.

There is no ethics rule which prohibits judges from holding a testimonial dinner. A judge may also be an honoree at a testimonial dinner, MCJC 5C(4)(a). Where the event is a charitable fund-raising event, however, a judge honoree may attend the event only if the proceeds of the dinner are allocated to a charitable or civic purpose, JI-9.

We have no indication that the testimonial dinner in this inquiry is intended to be "fund-raising"; rather, it appears that any contribution of funds would be simply to cover the costs of the event. It is commonplace for groups to hold meetings in public facilities which rent out private rooms and offer standard menus for various set rates, depending on attendance. Some facilities require an advance deposit or a minimum attendance guarantee. Advising attendees of their pro rata share for attendance at the event is not, in our view, prohibited "solicitation of funds."

Likewise, if one event organizer has advanced a deposit, it is not improper for the individual to be reimbursed from payments from attendees subsequently received. There is no need to create elaborate bookkeeping or separate accounts. Any reasonable method of determining each attendee's share and reimbursing the organizer for any advance payments is acceptable.

Finally, since we are assuming that the nature of the event is not fund-raising, there are no "proceeds" or outside income to report under MCJC 6.

If the event were intended to be fund-raising, the nature of the group holding the event and whether the funds are raised for MCJC 5B purposes would be significant. Pursuant to MCJC 5B(2), judges may not solicit funds for educational, religious, charitable, fraternal or civic organizations. But see JI-33, which concluded that an organization of judges may solicit through a nonjudge officer. Under those circumstances only a nonjudge would be able to handle the collection, deposit, and allocation of the funds received. Since the funds would be handled by a nonjudge, there would be no reporting required under MCJC 6.

 
     

 

follow us
Follow Us on Facebook Follow Us on LinkedIn Follow Us on Twitter Follow the SBM Blog

 

©Copyright 2014

website links
Contact Us
Site Map
Website Privacy Statement PDF
Staff Links

SBM on the Mapcontact information
State Bar of Michigan
306 Townsend St
Lansing, MI 48933-2012
Phone: (517) 346-6300
Toll Free: (800) 968-1442
Fax: (517) 482-6248