View Online
   
 
 
 
July 2017
 
 
“Substantial Burden”: Limits on the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act

By Katelyn Young, Bodman PLC

Congress enacted the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) to protect the fundamental right to religious freedom with respect to real property and land use. 42 U.S.C. § 2000cc. RLUIPA does not, however, provide religious institutions a blanket exemption from land-use regulations, nor does it create a cause of action regarding land use simply because a religious institution is involved.

Not just any impact on a religious exercise will constitute a violation of RLUIPA. The land use or regulatory burden must be substantial. Although RLUIPA does not define a “substantial burden,” the Sixth Circuit just issued the only published RLUIPA opinion in the circuit. The Court established just how difficult it is to meet the substantial burden test; simply putting forth evidence of a mere inconvenience will not suffice.

In Livingston Christian Schs. (LCS) v. Genoa Charter Twp. (CA6, No. 17a0117.06, April 26, 2017), the church applied for a special use permit to build a school. The Court relied on several factors to determine the township’s denial did not violate RLUIPA: (1) the availability of a reasonable, alternate location; (2) whether the regulation caused undue delay or expense; and (3) whether the burden from the regulation was self-imposed. The Court concluded that the burden on LCS was self-imposed when they leased that property after the special use permit was denied.

Compare this to the recent Department of Justice settlement with the City of Des Plaines, IL (finding a RLUIPA violation for misapplied zoning laws for a Muslim religious organization). LCS’s argument seems based on business, not religion. LCS alleged that the denial would have negative impacts on their revenue and enrollment rates, but failed to identify any religious or traditionally secular activity that they could not perform on their original property.

 
 
 
 
The Real Property Law Academy is Coming!

RPLS Academy

This fall, the Real Property Law Section is launching a new continuing education program, the Real Property Law Academy. The Academy is modeled in large part after the successful Business Bootcamp held by the Business Law Section. The Academy is being taught by some of the most respected and experienced Michigan real estate attorneys. The goal is to provide a basic understanding of the most fundamental aspects of a real estate practice. The Academy is targeted for both real estate attorneys and other attorneys who will periodically encounter real estate issues.

The program is being presented in two parts (Academy I and Academy II). Each part will present eight topics over a consecutive two day period. Academy I will focus on purchase agreements, due diligence, commercial financing, closings, commercial leasing, condominiums, summary proceedings and quiet title actions, and introductory zoning issues.

Academy II will focus on topics that require a deeper dive and may include property taxation, zoning litigation, insurance, condemnation, construction, mineral rights, construction, and other issues that a real estate practitioner will confront. Participants are highly encouraged to attend both Academy I and Academy II to get the full benefits from the program.

Academy I will be held in Grand Rapids on October 11-12, 2017, and in Troy on May 9-10, 2018.

Academy II will be held in Grand Rapids in fall, 2018 and in the metro Detroit area in spring, 2019.

Academy Benefits

  • Gain a basic understanding of the fundamentals of Michigan real estate practice.
  • Develop confidence, attract clients, and impress partners.
  • Meet some of the leading Michigan real estate lawyers.
  • Take away time-tested, basic forms and explanatory materials you can put to use immediately.
  • Network with other real estate practitioners.
Discounts are available for firms. Register now: online or by mail form
 
 
 
 
 
Join a Committee

Take the opportunity to get involved by writing for one of our publications, presenting at a conference or seminar, or joining one of the committees that cover virtually every area in real estate law. See our committees and how you can join or see the committees you're already subscribed to.

Note to Committee Members:
Communication settings for RPLS Special Committee members have been changed to "Daily Digest." This means when a message is posted on your Committee page, you will receive the message the day it is posted.

 
 
 
 
 

Sign Up Today!

July 19-22, 2017
Summer Conference
Grand Traverse Resort & Spa
Register: online or by mail form
Book a Room or call (800) 968-7352 and mention the SBM0717 to receive the discounted rate.

 

 

 
 
 
 
 
Write an Article

Interested in writing an article for the e-Newsletter? Please contact co-editors Gregory J. Gamalski at ggamalski@bodmanlaw.com, Howard Lax at HLax@bodmanlaw.com, or Patricia Paruch at Pat.Paruch@kkue.com.