Columns

Another pox on prior to

 

by Joseph Kimble   |   Michigan Bar Journal

Plain Language

I poxed this useless phrase decades ago. Now I’m re-poxing. It continues to run rampant.

REFERENCES:

Theodore M. Bernstein, The Careful Writer 346 (Atheneum, 1972):

Prior to is a “faddish affectation for before. Would you say posterior to in place of after?”

Peter Butt, Modern Legal Drafting 242 (Cambridge University Press, 3d ed, 2013): Do not use prior to. Use before [in a list of “verbose forms”].

Roy H. Copperud, American Usage and Style: The Consensus 305 (Van Nostrand Reinhold Co, 1980): Prior to is “pompous in the sense before.”

Martin Cutts, Oxford Guide to Plain English 148 (Oxford University Press, 5th ed, 2020): “This pompous way of saying before tends to produce verb-free constructions: ‘Prior to the abandonment of the mine by the company’ instead of ‘Before the company abandoned the mine.’”

Bryan A. Garner, A Dictionary of Modern Legal Usage 708 (Oxford University Press, 3d ed, 2011): “Prior to is a terribly overworked lawyerism. Only in rare contexts is it not much inferior to before.”

Sir Ernest Gowers, Plain Words: A Guide to the Use of English 200 (Penguin Books, Rebecca Gowers, rev ed, 2015): “There is no good reason to use prior to as a preposition instead of before. Before is simpler, better known and more natural, and therefore preferable.”

Joseph Kimble, A Modest Wish List for Legal Writing, 79 Mich B J 1574, 1577 (2000): “Prior to takes the booby prize for the most common inflated phrase in legal and official writing. Why would anyone prefer it to before? Try to think of a single literary title or line that uses prior to. . . . By itself, prior to may seem insignificant. But it often leads to clumsy, indirect constructions . . . . More important, a fondness for prior to may indicate a fondness for jargon—and a blind resistance to using plain words. That resistance, that cast of mind, is in large part responsible for the state of legal writing.”


“Plain Language,” edited by Joseph Kimble, has been a regular feature of the Michigan Bar Journal for 42 years. To contribute an article, contact Prof. Kimble at Cooley Law School, 300 S. Capitol Ave., Lansing, MI 48933, or at kimblej@cooley.edu. For an index of past columns, visit www.michbar.org/plainlanguage.