WHAT IS TDIU?
A veteran can obtain a 100% rating through one of two ways: through all of their service-connected disabilities combining to 95% or higher, or by securing TDIU. 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(a) states that total ratings may be assigned where the schedular rating is less than total when the disabled person is, in the judgment of the rating agency, unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of service-connected disabilities.1 To be eligible for schedular TDIU, one disability must be rated at 60% or more, and if there are multiple disabilities, at least one must be rated no less than 40% for a combined rating of 70% or more.2
IMPORTANT CASELAW PRIOR TO THE PASSAGE OF THE AMA
In Comer v. Peake, the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit (Federal Circuit) held that a claim for TDIU was “not a free-standing claim that must be pled with specificity; it is implicitly raised whenever a pro se veteran, who presents cogent evidence of unemployability, seeks to obtain a higher disability rating.”3 Later that year, in Rice v. Shinseki, the United States Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC) considered the definition of “claim” for TDIU.4 Here, the Court held a request for TDIU, whether expressly raised by a veteran or reasonably raised by the record, “is not a separate claim for benefits, but rather involves an attempt to obtain an appropriate rating for a disability or disabilities, either as part of the initial adjudication of a claim or, if a disability upon which entitlement to TDIU is based has already been found to be service connected, as part of a claim for increased compensation.”5 Later, in Harper v. Wilkie, the CAVC found that if a claimant files a notice of disagreement seeking a higher evaluation for a service-connected disability and, during the processing of that appeal, files a request for TDIU based on the same disability, the request for TDIU is combined with the overall appeal unless and until the claimant is either granted TDIU for the entire period on appeal or withdraws the appeal.6
PASSAGE OF THE AMA
Prior to passage of the AMA, appeals under the legacy system went along a single pathway. Claimants unsatisfied with an initial decision of the Regional Office (RO) had one year to file a notice of disagreement, which triggered the Department of Veterans Affairs’ (VA) obligation to produce a Statement of the Case (SOC).7 Following issuance of the SOC, claimants had 60 days to file a substantive appeal, triggering certification to and review by the Board of Veterans’ Appeals (Board).8 Following an unfavorable Board decision, claimants had 120 days to file a Notice of Appeal with the CAVC, as a last resort.9
Effective February 19, 2019, the VA implemented the AMA as much needed comprehensive reform for the legacy administrative appeals process.10 Instead of having only one appeal option after a decision, veterans now have three different avenues to appeal an unfavorable decision. Within one year of the RO’s decision, claimants may file one of the following: (1) a request for higher-level review of that decision; (2) a supplemental claim; or (3) a notice of disagreement to directly appeal to the Board.11 In addition to providing post-decision review options, the AMA introduced statutory language referencing a “continuously pursued claim.” 38 U.S.C. § 5110 was revised to allow for an effective date as early as the initial application for benefits whenever the claimant continuously pursues a claim by filing, either alone or in succession: (1) a request for a higher-level review, (2) a supplemental claim, (3) a notice of disagreement, (4) a supplemental claim within one year of a Board decision, or (5) a supplemental claim within one year of a CAVC decision.12
TDIU AFTER THE PASSAGE OF THE AMA
In Green v. McDonough, the Board denied entitlement to TDIU because claimant Green did not have any service-connected disabilities at the time of the agency of original jurisdiction’s (AOJ) decision on appeal — even though the Board granted Green’s service connection for a disability in that same decision. The Board determined that, because Green did not have any service-connected disabilities at the time of the 2019 statement of the case, entitlement to TDIU must be denied as a matter of law. The Board also ruled that its grant of service connection for an acquired psychiatric disorder in that same decision could not be considered in the AMA appeals system because its decision was limited to the facts and evidence in the record at the time of the 2019 decision on appeal.13 The Board found that it could not remand entitlement to TDIU because remand was only appropriate under the AMA if there was a pre-decisional duty to assist error.14 The CAVC disagreed, finding that the Board could remand for correction of any other error by the AOJ in satisfying a regulatory or statutory duty, if correction of the error would have a reasonable possibility of aiding the appellant’s claim’s substantiation.15
Just a few months later, the CAVC was again forced to address what TDIU would look like in the AMA. In Phillips v. McDonough, claimant Phillips argued that the Board had an obligation to consider a TDIU effective date further back than one year prior to his April 2021 formal TDIU application, since his skin condition claim had been pending since 2002, and his April 2021 TDIU application indicated that both his PTSD and skin conditions prevented employability.16 The Secretary argued that, because AMA had specific paths for review, and those paths had their own record limitations and prohibitions on concurrent selection, AMA precluded Phillips’ other claims, which were already in higher-level review.17 The CAVC reiterated its prior caselaw in finding that, even if a claim is specifically labeled as a claim for TDIU, the VA is obligated to determine all potential claims raised by the evidence.18 TDIU is not a separate claim but an attempt for the original claim to be rated correctly.19 The CAVC determined that because TDIU is not a separate claim, the grant or denial of TDIU for part of a claim stream or in a separate claim stream does not absolve the VA from responsibility to consider TDIU as part of another stream for the entire period on appeal.20 This means that if the RO grants or denies TDIU as part of one increased rating claim, the VA may still be required to consider TDIU in a separate appeal of a different rating if the veteran does not already have the maximum benefits.21 However, the majority ultimately found that because Phillips only brought PTSD before the Board as an issue for a higher rating, but not his skin rating, the effective date was controlled by his April 2021 TDIU application.22
More recently, in Witkowski v. Collins, the CAVC dealt with the concept of extra-schedular TDIU, or entitlement to TDIU where a veteran does not have at least a 60% rating (if only one disability) or 70% combined, as previously discussed. Claimant Witkowski argued that the Board should grant extra-schedular TDIU instead of remanding his case to the director of compensation services for extra-schedular consideration.23 Previously, in Bowling v. Principi, the CAVC had held that the Board could not award extra-schedular TDIU without referring the matter to the director for consideration, according to 38 C.F.R. § 4.16(b).24 The ensuing procedure was complex: The Board had to consider whether there was a reasonable possibility that extra-schedular TDIU existed before referring it to the director; if so, the director would then determine whether TDIU benefits were actually warranted, and then the RO would incorporate the director’s decision, which could be appealed by the applicant to the Board.25 Here, in Witkowski, the CAVC overruled Bowling’s holding and determined simply that the Board could decide extra-schedular TDIU itself.26
WHAT’S NEXT?
While the passage of the AMA brought necessary changes to the VA appeals system, it also brought uncertainty about how claims would be adjudicated. Phillips, arguably the most consequential decision concerning TDIU in this new appeals world, presents questions about whether veterans must appeal every VA rating decision — even those they agree with — to protect the earliest possible effective date for TDIU. In her dissent in Phillips, Judge Bartley emphasized that this will clog an “already overstretched VA claims process and harm[ ] veterans who may not know how to file protective appeals.”27 Phillips reiterated that Rice is still good law under the AMA but failed to apply Rice’s ultimate holding to its decision: that an assertion of unemployability within one year of a decision, which grants service connection and assigns an initial evaluation, abates that decision’s finality, potentially affording a veteran’s entitlement to TDIU as part of their initial award of benefits.28 The potential earliest effective date under Rice could be as early as the date of the claim for service connection and not, as the VA previously believed, only one year before the submission of a TDIU application.29 The majority ruling in Phillips, according to Judge Bartley in her dissent, “limits a claimant’s potential recovery and sanctions a claim prosecution view for TDIU that gives outsize impact to a claimant’s inexpert medical and vocational decision about which service-connected disability or disabilities are causing or contributing to unemployability, which evaluation decision to appeal, and which lane to choose.”30 The majority’s decision makes a veteran’s failure to appeal a decision, even if they agree with it, consequential for the TDIU effective date. According to Judge Bartley, this result is contrary to the CAVC’s intent in Rice and the Congressional intent to streamline an already burdened system with the AMA reforms.31 It is therefore unclear, and the CAVC did not explain, why the AMA would abrogate the VA’s responsibility to fully adjudicate TDIU whenever raised.32 Most fundamentally, the majority did not explain why the Board was not required to consider all of a veteran’s service-connected disabilities when evaluating TDIU, as has been the case for many years and as is apparently still good law under 38 C.F.R. § 4.16, and instead only had to consider TDIU as it related to the issues on appeal before the Board.33
Judge Bartley’s dissent in Phillips presents important and unanswered questions about when TDIU can be raised, what appeals stream it can be raised in, what must be appealed, what appeal options must be utilized, and what conditions can be considered when evaluating TDIU. Although 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 did not change with the passage of the AMA, as Judge Bartley correctly noted, the majority’s interpretation of that regulation did change with its decision in Phillips. Now, the Board’s consideration of the TDIU effective date is tied to the underlying claim stream before it, although the VA must still consider all of a veteran’s service-connected disabilities when determining entitlement to TDIU. Going forward, advocates may feel forced to appeal every rating decision issued if TDIU may be a factor down the road. Even if the veteran is presently working, if there is a possibility they may not work in the future and need TDIU to achieve 100%, an advocate may be wary of not appealing every rating decision to avoid foreclosing a potentially early effective date for TDIU. This creates confusion for veterans and also for their advocates. It also puts both in a precarious position, as appealing some rating decisions could result in further examinations and a potential reduction, rather than sustaining or increasing the rating. However, if TDIU may be a factor, an advocate or veteran may feel that appeal of that rating decision is ultimately necessary. This will result in more appeals and more strain on the VA system, which is exactly what the AMA was designed to prevent.
Going forward into this ever-evolving VA system, advocates would be wise to appeal any rating decisions that could potentially impact the future award of TDIU. If a veteran’s conditions on appeal impact their ability to obtain and maintain substantially gainful employment, advocates should reiterate that the VA must consider the impact of all service-connected disabilities on their ability to work, as 38 C.F.R. § 4.16 instructs. Though rating reductions remain a concern at the VA, it is worth pursuing an appeal to obtain the earliest possible effective date for TDIU. Because of the majority’s reliance on appeal stream and election lanes under the AMA in the Phillips decision, advocates should also consider streamlining their appeals into one lane to avoid any Board refusal to consider service-connected conditions outside of the individually appealed claim.
TDIU does not exist in a vacuum; at its core, it is a rating provision that provides an alternate way for a veteran to receive a 100% disability rating based on their service-connected conditions impacting their ability to work. It does not have to be explicitly raised, even under the AMA, and may be reasonably raised by the record. While caselaw continues to evolve on this issue, advocates should still rely on Rice in arguing for the earliest possible effective date for TDIU, to ensure that veterans receive the benefits they are entitled to.