“All of our witnesses provide examples of why we work to support veterans when they transition out of the military, and the value they add to our communities and our country after their service when that transition goes well.”
– Senator Jerry Moran, Chair of the United States Senate Committee on Veterans' Affairs, April 15, 2026
On April 15, 2026, the United States Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs held a hearing on “Programs for Justice-Involved Veterans” and heard testimony on the impact of veterans treatment courts (VTCs).1 The hearing highlighted the effectiveness of VTCs, which provide treatment and support to justice-involved veterans diagnosed with mental health and substance use disorders, in lieu of incarceration. Throughout the hearing, the Committee expressed its strong, bipartisan support for continued funding to expand and strengthen VTCs.
As a VTC judge in Ingham County, it was gratifying to hear the statistics and stories illustrating the positive impact VTCs have on veterans’ lives. However, having had the privilege of seeing veterans’ success in a VTC firsthand, this information was not new.
What was new to me was the focus on veterans’ transition from the military to civilian life. Again and again, witnesses detailed the challenges veterans face during this transition and called for the military to make transition a priority mission.
Until the military fully achieves this mission, VTCs will continue to play a central role in helping veterans successfully transition from service member to community member. Michigan VTCs have the tools, resources, and experience to help veterans reintegrate in their communities. In fact, as discussed in this article, Michigan VTCs are doing this work in line with national recommendations, often in innovative ways.
RISK FACTORS FOR JUSTICE-INVOLVED VETERANS
“You won’t find a veteran in VTC with just one problem. You will find layers of problems, all of which led to that unfortunate intersection with law enforcement.”
– Clyde “Butch” Tate, Major General, U.S. Army (Ret). Chief Counsel, All Rise,2 Senate Committee on Veterans' Affairs, April 15, 2026
Each year, roughly 245,000 service members transition from military to civilian life.3 More than 25% of all veterans and 44% of post-9/11 veterans experience readjustment challenges.4 These challenges can lead to contact with the criminal justice system.5 Approximately one-third of veterans report a history of arrest, compared to one-fifth of the nonveteran population.6 The reasons why veterans are more likely to have contact with the criminal justice system are multifaceted. Three categories of risk factors emerge: veteran characteristics (individual-level risk factors), veteran experiences during or related to military service (service-related risk factors), and veteran experiences following military service (post-service risk factors).7
These categories recognize that the factors that put a veteran at risk for justice involvement exist before, during, and after military service.8 Simply put, upon entering the military, service members are more likely than their civilian counterparts to have socioeconomic and family characteristics, adverse childhood experiences (ACEs), and personality traits that increase risk of criminal justice involvement.9 During their service, combat exposure, military sexual trauma, and physical and mental health problems — such as posttraumatic stress disorder, traumatic brain injury, mental health disorders, and substance use disorders — increase the risk of justice involvement.10 Finally, post-service, veterans experience stress related to relationships, finances, housing, health care, and barriers to care.11 All these factors — individually and cumulatively — place a veteran at risk for justice involvement and demonstrate why the military must adequately support service members as they transition to civilian life.
MICHIGAN VTCS: HELPING VETERANS BRIDGE THE TRANSITION TO CIVILIAN LIFE
“After my final deployment, I tried to adjust to being home, but without the structure of the military, I drifted. I understand now that my drinking and drug use was my way of coping with a life I didn’t know how to live.”
– Corey Schramm, Veteran, U.S. Army and VTC Graduate, Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs, April 15, 2026
Like other treatment courts, VTCs provide needed structure, treatment, and accountability to participants. VTCs are unique, however, because they exclusively serve veterans in a military-connected environment. In a VTC, the participant receives a veteran mentor, connects with a Veteran Justice Outreach Specialist (VJO), and engages in medical treatment and services at the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). The reason for these specialized treatment courts just for veterans is simple: “Veterans do better with other veterans.”12
Michigan is a national leader in providing access to VTCs, with 30 VTCs across the state. In fact, Michigan was an early adopter of VTCs, with the first programs established in 2010. Michigan VTCs follow state and federal guidelines and best practices.13 Accordingly, Michigan VTCs have a record of helping veterans successfully transition into civilian life and reintegrate into their families and communities.
In doing their work, Michigan VTCs address problems caused by deficiencies in the military’s approach to transition.14 In many ways, Michigan VTCs have implemented current recommendations being considered by the military to address these problems: Michigan VTCs timely identify justice-involved veterans. They alleviate the problem of “bad paper” discharges. And they engage community partners to meet the variety of veterans’ legal needs, particularly with expungement.
Identifying justice-involved veterans
“There are an awful lot of jails in this country that they have no idea if the people [in their jail] are veterans. The simple matter of asking people when they are being booked, ‘Have you served in the military?’ helps.”
– The Honorable Lawton Nuss, Chief Justice (Ret.), Kansas Supreme Court, Senate Committee on Veterans' Affairs, April 15, 2026
There are no reliable estimates of how many veterans are incarcerated or have had contact with the justice system.15 Not all veterans self-identify as a veteran. Some may choose not to identify themselves out of shame or fear of the consequences to their benefits. Although the VA has created tools to allow law enforcement, jails, and courts to independently verify veteran status, use of these systems is extremely low.16
Michigan is ahead of the curve in addressing this problem. The Michigan Veteran Connector’s public service campaign teaches the most effective question to ask to identify a veteran. Do not ask, “Are you a veteran?” Rather, ask, “Have you served in the military?”17
VTCs can work with justice partners to establish a process to timely identify incarcerated veterans. In our VTC, the Ingham County jail sends our VJO a weekly list of inmates. The VJO reviews and identifies any veterans in the VA’s system. The VJO then follows up with the veteran and communicates with the prosecutor. Similarly, at the Lansing City jail, a Lansing Police Department social worker, who is also a veteran and part of the treatment team, reviews the city jail data and provides the VJO and the prosecutor a weekly list of any veteran who has had police contact. Furthermore, both the Ingham County Prosecutor’s Office and Public Defender’s Office have a special veteran designation box on their intake forms to help identify veterans. These efforts help to identify justice-involved veterans early so they can be linked to the VA and considered for a VTC if appropriate.
The problem of “bad paper” discharges
“What has happened over time is that those most in need of [VA] benefits are denied benefits. ...”
– David “Mac” MacEwen, Brigadier General, U.S. Army (Ret.), Director, Veterans Justice Commission, Council on Criminal Justice, Senate Committee on Veterans' Affairs, April 15, 2026
Upon separation from the military, every service member is assigned a “character of service,” often referred to as their discharge papers.18 An honorable discharge is the only type that carries no barriers to veteran benefits and services. All other discharges — namely general, other than honorable, bad conduct, and dishonorable discharges — can create barriers and are considered “bad paper” discharges.19 A bad paper discharge affects whether and to what extent a former service member may be eligible for VA benefits.
Recently, bad paper discharges are increasing, perhaps in part due to difficulties identifying and supporting service members whose performance is affected by the individual and service-related risk factors discussed above.20 As a result, more veterans are starting their transition to civilian life without access to health care and other VA services, putting them at higher risk of suicide and justice involvement.21 In response to this problem, witnesses at the Senate hearing called for the VA to adopt regulations that would provide VA eligibility to all former service members who were not discharged under dishonorable conditions.
A national survey of VTCs found that 35% do not permit veterans with bad paper discharges.22 Michigan VTCs have not adopted this exclusion from admission. To the contrary, Michigan’s current VTC statute expressly permits the admission of veterans who have been “discharged or released under conditions other than dishonorable.”23 This definition is consistent with current recommendations as well as the plain text of the 1944 GI Bill.24 Moreover, the Michigan Legislature is currently considering legislation that would further expand eligibility. Specifically, House Bill 6028 of 2026 would allow veterans who were dishonorably discharged to participate in a VTC “if the individual has been diagnosed with a service-connected substance-use disorder, military sexual trauma, traumatic brain injury, post-traumatic stress disorder, or another mental health condition.”25
Michigan veterans who are not eligible for VA benefits because of a bad paper discharge or other reason may still fully participate in Michigan’s VTCs. A VTC can partner with non-VA community-based treatment providers to deliver treatment to veterans who are not VA eligible. Our VTC takes this approach, and thanks to state grant funding, non-VA treatment for these veterans is subsidized.
Community partnerships for access to legal services and expungement
“I believe that government, the judiciary, and community partners have never looked better than they look with Veterans Treatment Courts.”
– Clyde “Butch” Tate, Major General, U.S. Army (Ret). Chief Counsel, All Rise, Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs, April 15, 2026
A justice-involved veteran is likely to benefit from access to legal services for a variety of issues, including housing, family law, driver’s license restoration, and expungement. Expungement—the legal process of removing a conviction from the public record — is especially important for justice-involved veterans to fully reintegrate into their families and communities. Having a criminal record creates barriers to employment, housing, education, loans, professional licensure, and volunteering in the community, including at a veteran’s child’s school.
Experts at the Senate hearing advocated for the adoption of laws to establish or expand expungement policies for veterans. Some states have sentencing statutes for veterans that permit courts to order that the sentencing offense be made nonpublic under certain conditions.26 The rationale for these laws seems indisputable. As California’s statute succinctly states: “It is in the interests of justice to restore a defendant who acquired a criminal record due to a mental health disorder stemming from service in the United States military to the community of law-abiding citizens.”27
Some states have gone further. In New Jersey, state courts “may order the expungement of all records and information relating to all prior arrests, detentions, convictions, and proceedings” upon successful discharge from “special probation” in a recovery treatment court.28 The scope of this benefit bears repeating. Under certain circumstances, this law allows treatment court participants to expunge not only the offense that brought them into a treatment court but their entire criminal history, thereby fully restoring the individual to the community of law-abiding citizens. This incredible incentive for participants to succeed and not reoffend continues after they leave court supervision because if they are convicted of “any crime following discharge from special probation, the full record of arrests and convictions may be restored to public access and no future expungement shall be granted to such person.”29
New Jersey’s statute illustrates the breadth of benefit that could be granted to successful treatment court graduates. It could be a model for how the Michigan Legislature could go further to expand expungement for veterans. Until that happens, Michigan VTCs have other ways to help veterans clear their criminal records under existing law.
The Veteran Treatment Court statute allows for discharge and dismissal of the charge(s) for which the veteran was admitted to VTC.30 If the veteran is successful, no conviction enters, and all records of the arrest and the dismissal are nonpublic.31
Additionally, thanks to Michigan Clean Slate laws, veterans — like all individuals — have expanded access to expungement.32 Recognizing the importance of expungement, our VTC in Ingham County ensures that every veteran receives legal advice on expungement before they leave the program.
To this end, the Friends of the Ingham County Treatment Court, a nonprofit organization formed to support our VTC, recruits attorneys to provide pro bono legal assistance on expungement to each veteran before graduation. The attorney reviews the veteran’s criminal history for expungement-eligible convictions, consults with the veteran, and if expungement can be pursued, the attorney represents the veteran through the process, with the Friends covering all associated costs. As a result of this initiative, every veteran has a plan for expungement before they graduate, and some have cleared their entire criminal record.
As these initiatives illustrate, Michigan continues to be a leader in using VTCs to successfully transition justice-involved veterans into their communities. However, we can go further; specifically, we could do more to restore veterans who complete a VTC to the community of law-abiding citizens through broader expungement laws. Our success in this regard depends on the commitment of many stakeholders, including our elected representatives. Having had the privilege of working with justice-involved veterans and seeing firsthand the value they add to our communities and our country after their service, I look forward to being a part of these efforts.