At the end of the day, lawyers care about their clients. We want to help them meet their goals and solve their problems. Usually, it is “smiles and handshakes” after that first meeting.
You, the practicing lawyer, sometimes have the answer to those problems or the ability to find out what the answer is. Some days you are heralded as a hero; other days you are a zero. It’s great to give good news to your clients but some days you are the bearer of bad news. Remember, you are not being paid to give good news or make people happy; you are an attorney. You use your legal training to analyze the facts, determine potential approaches and outcomes, and present them to your client. Sometimes it is too late to do anything, sometimes the client’s choice is between two or more unwanted outcomes. The hardest part is not involving your emotions in the work you do and the decisions you need to make.
Taking on a new case is your choice. Setting your fees and terms of representation is your choice. The client will not come in with a retainer for you to sign nor will the client dictate terms for you. The key to maintaining control of the situation is to remember that you are in charge of the attorney-client relationship. The client has a say about his or her case, but you are in charge of the relationship.
INTERVIEWING AND RETAINING NEW CLIENTS
Effective prospect meetings involve 4 phases:
Understanding what the prospect’s issues are and what their desired outcome would be
This means actively listening to the prospect and letting them say what they need to say. You may be the first person who is letting them speak their mind.
Demonstrate your understanding of the prospect’s issues and clarify your interpretation of what you were told and understand
After listening to the prospect, ask clarifying questions to things you do not understand. Find out if other attempts have been made to address their issues, especially if other lawyers have been involved. Determine the importance of resolving the matter and its relative value to the prospect. Ask about any deadlines and establish a possible timeline of relevant events. The answer to these questions could affect how and if you will accept the prospect’s matter in your office.
Discuss possible approaches to the prospect’s issues
Without committing to a specific course of action, the attorney may present some general approaches that potentially address the prospect’s concerns. Until you have spent the requisite time reviewing the issues in detail, it would be premature to describe precisely how you would address the prospect’s issues. This is the time to provide clear caveats and risks that any potential approach has.
Discuss the financial requirements of retaining your services
If you understand the prospect’s problems and reasonably believe you can provide services to the prospect, ask the prospect if they are interested in hiring you. If they are interested, then you have the responsibility of explaining your fees, how they are charged, how they are calculated and how you expect to be paid. A great question to ask the prospect is, “Have you ever hired a lawyer before?” If the answer is no, carefully explain to the prospect what you do and let them know you will reduce your terms and policies to writing.
You may get some feedback in the form of surprise or an admission that the prospect cannot afford your services. If that is the case, it is better to know that upfront before committing to a lot of work and no or slow payment. Some prospects may want to negotiate your rate or haggle over terms. That is for the attorney to determine if they are willing to amend their agreements or reduce their hourly rate. Whatever those terms would be, if an attorney accepts them, the attorney must abide by them.
Another good way to make a meeting efficient is by providing prospects with an information sheet to complete prior to the meeting. Not only do completed forms save time, prospects who do not complete the forms may be signaling that they may become future problems.1
KEY POINTS TO REMEMBER IN MANAGING THE ATTORNEY CLIENT RELATIONSHIP
Everything in writing – Everyone has memory issues. A good retainer agreement with an appropriate number of different versions for different types of representation gives all parties notice of how the relationship will proceed. It needs to be detailed enough to address issues like payment, each party’s responsibilities, communications, default, withdrawal, payment terms, to name a few. A written agreement serves not only as guidance on how you will work together, but how you will work through your differences and how the relationship may end.
In addition to your retainer, you are bound by your oath and by the Michigan Rules of Professional Conduct. Clients neither take an oath nor are they bound by any rules. The ICLE has many examples of effective retainer agreements as do SBM’s legal specialty sections.2
Remember it is a business relationship – You may make a personal connection with clients in the process of representation. That is normal. But this is not a personal relationship; it is a business relationship. You need to have frank discussions with clients about your expectations of them, a clear discussion about fees and costs, and their responsibility to you. Know what your fees are going to be upfront, the terms of payment, and do everything in writing. Do not take any action until you are paid.
Access to you – Have a communications policy and let your clients know what it is. Unless you set forth boundaries, clients do not know better and just assume you are available 24/7.
Know who you are – Know what your skill sets are, what your limitations are, and do your best to stay within those parameters. The client needs to know what you do and what your experience is, and when specialists in other areas of the law may be needed. Otherwise, all he or she knows is that you are an attorney and said you will get the job done for them. If somewhere down the line you do not know what you are doing, do not expect your client to lend you a sympathetic ear.
Stay on the high road – Even when the attorney-client relationship breaks down, it is incumbent on you to maintain your standards and respect the individual while he or she is still a client.
Document everything – Keep track of everything that goes on between you and your client. Emails, letters, calls, etc.
WHEN DOES THE ATTORNEY CLIENT RELATIONSHIP END?
The retainer agreement can set forth the end of the professional relationship. If the attorney is performing a specific service, the performance ought to be the end of the relationship. If it is a long-term relationship, the parties will end the relationship as determined. A client can always end the relationship on command. There does not need to be a showing of good cause.
Not only should the retainer contain information on how the attorney-client relationship will end, but it is also a good policy to send a closing letter to the client. This removes any doubt when the relationship comes to a close.
CONCLUSION
Maintaining a healthy relationship with your clients begins with a transparent intake process, a solid agreement, and adherence to its terms. Clear communication goes a long way to fostering trust. Honesty with the client about their matter engenders trust even when you only have bad news to deliver.