Columns

Evolutionary psychology: The ultimate life hack

 

by Thomas J. Grden   |   Michigan Bar Journal

Practicing Wellness

Karl Marx famously lauded the sections of Charles Darwin’s On the Origin of Species that reinforced his worldview while dismissing the parts that proved inconvenient — presaging the selective, echo-chamber style of communication that dominates modern social media.1 Yet, like much of his broader framework, Marx’s emphasis on “the ensemble of social relations”2 is dangerously flawed and ignores the biological truth of human development: Evolution did not cease upon the advent of human culture. While it is convenient to posture that modern human beings are born as an infinitely adaptable “blank slate” that completely transcends biology, in reality, the modern human is an ancient organism navigating novel environments with prehistoric biological hardware.

Unfortunately, modern legal practice creates a severe mismatch between these ancestral adaptations and daily working conditions, leading to chronic stress, burnout, and clinical anxiety. Thankfully, awareness of these autonomous processes, and deliberate action to counteract them, can significantly ease the distress of evolutionary mismatch. It’s even possible to leverage our automatic reflexes to our own advantage in the pursuit of health and wellbeing.

COUNTERING THE HYPERVIGILANCE TRAP

The relentless demands of modern litigation and corporate practice force attorneys into what can be termed the “hypervigilance trap.” In our ancestral environment, human survival depended on hyper-responsive threat detection — a constant, subconscious scanning of the horizon for predators, hostile tribes, or sudden environmental hazards.3 Modern legal practice takes this ancient evolutionary adaptation and turns it into a high-powered, nonstop professional requirement. Lawyers are systematically trained to engage in perpetual risk assessment and issue-spotting, scanning every document, contract, and argument strictly for worst-case scenarios and hidden liabilities.

While this hyper-adapted cognitive mode is indispensable inside the courtroom or boardroom, maintaining it around the clock tricks our prehistoric nervous system into believing we are under continuous, life-threatening attack. To escape this trap, attorneys must first recognize that professional issue-spotting is a deliberate mental state rather than a permanent default. Building intentional transition rituals — such as changing out of work clothes immediately upon returning home, taking a brief walk between tasks, or physically putting away work devices — signals to the brain that threat scanning is temporarily suspended.

DE-ESCALATING THE “TRIBE UNDER ATTACK” RESPONSE

This ancient threat-detection mechanism becomes doubly problematic when combined with our deeply ingrained tribal instincts, creating what can be understood as the “Tribe Under Attack” response. For early humans, conflict with an opposing group represented an existential threat to life, family, and community, triggering a massive surge of adrenaline and cortisol to prepare the body for immediate, violent survival.4 Modern legal practice constantly pokes this ancient evolutionary sore spot; receiving a hostile motion from opposing counsel or reading an aggressive email from a litigious adversary can trigger a physiological stress response involving hormones such as adrenaline and cortisol.

Unlike an acute physical threat, however, modern legal conflict often leaves attorneys seated at a desk with little physical outlet for that stress response. To de-escalate this biological alarm system, lawyers must leverage cognitive reframing: consciously recognizing that an adversarial attack is not a physical threat to life or status but rather a procedural game governed by artificial rules. By deliberately reclassifying hostile communications as abstract professional maneuvers rather than existential battles, attorneys can disarm the automatic fight-or-flight cascade and preserve their mental and physical wellbeing.

REBUILDING TRIBAL CONNECTION & REDUCING ISOLATION

Compounding these cognitive stressors is a profound social mismatch: the stark isolation of modern practice, which directly conflicts with our nature as obligate social creatures. Early humans survived by remaining tightly embedded within small, interdependent tribes where shared effort, trust, and mutual protection were nonnegotiable for staying alive. In stark contrast, today’s legal environment forces attorneys into solitary, desk-bound shifts where client confidentiality rules and internal firm competition actively insulate them from genuine community support.

To an ancient nervous system, social isolation signals extreme vulnerability and heightened mortality risk, keeping baseline anxiety chronically elevated. Lawyers can counter this biological penalty by deliberately rebuilding their tribal support networks: cultivating a trusted peer group where vulnerabilities can be voiced without professional judgment and prioritizing face-to-face interactions over email or text. In-person interaction can strengthen social connection and help buffer stress in ways that digital communication may not fully replicate.

WORKING IN NATURAL CYCLES, NOT CONTINUOUS SPRINTS

Furthermore, our physical work patterns and office environments violate basic evolutionary defaults, fueling systemic burnout. Hunter-gatherers operated in natural cycles — bursts of intense physical and mental exertion during a hunt, followed by prolonged periods of low-intensity social rest, all governed by the natural rise and fall of the sun.5 The legal billable hour, however, demands continuous, uninterrupted cognitive sprints under high-contrast screens and artificial fluorescent lighting, starving the body of essential circadian cues and metabolic recovery.

To restore balance, attorneys must realign their daily habits with their biological programming. One practical approach is to structure work into focused blocks — for example, roughly 90 minutes of concentrated work followed by a restorative break — and to use those breaks to move physically and recover from sustained cognitive effort. Concurrently, seeking natural morning sunlight and incorporating daily “green time” outdoors provides the brain with the ancestral sensory inputs required to anchor circadian rhythms, improve sleep quality, and lower baseline nervous system arousal.6

MASTERING THE ANCIENT MACHINE

The practice of law will always be an intellectually demanding and inherently adversarial endeavor. However, the chronic distress, burnout, and anxiety experienced by so many legal professionals are not inevitable price tags of professional success — they are the predictable consequences of operating ancient biological machinery in an environment for which it was never designed. By moving past the myth of the “blank slate” and acknowledging our hardwired evolutionary design, lawyers can move from being passive victims of evolutionary mismatch to active managers of their own biology. Harnessing these ancient adaptations isn’t just good science; it is the ultimate strategy for building a sustainable, high-performing legal career.


“Practicing Wellness” is a regular column of the Michigan Bar Journal presented by the State Bar of Michigan Lawyers and Judges Assistance Program. If you’d like to contribute a guest column, please email contactljap@michbar.org.


ENDNOTES

1. See, e.g., Colp, The Contacts Between Karl Marx and Charles Darwin, 35 J of the History of Ideas 329-338 (1974).

2. Social Relations, The Great Dictionary of Marxism https://perma.cc/RRC5-GZTG (all websites accessed Oct 13, 2026).

3. Sharma, Why Our Brains Still React to Ancient Survival Threats, Psycho Peak (July 24, 2026) https://perma.cc/YW8U-BP3N.

4. Prehistoric Human Stress: Fact or Fiction? Exploring Ancient Anxiety, NeuroLaunch (Aug 18, 2024) https://perma.cc/JA7A-EN36.

5. What Are Hunters and Gatherers and How Did They Live?, Science Insights (March 25, 2026) https://perma.cc/NP92-LE2E.

6. Weir, Nurtured by Nature, 51 Am Psy Ass’n 3 (April, 2020) https://perma.cc/C3HZ-V94E.