News & Notices

From the Committee on Model Criminal Jury Instructions November 2026

 

Michigan Bar Journal

From the Committee on Model Criminal Jury Instructions

The Committee on Model Criminal Jury Instructions has adopted four new instructions on rioting offenses. M Crim JI 40.9 (Riot) addresses the crime set forth in MCL 752.541. M Crim JI 40.10 (Incitement to Riot) addresses the crime set forth in MCL 752.542. M Crim JI 40.10a (Incitement to Riot at Correctional Facility) addresses the crime set forth in MCL 752.542a. M Crim JI 40.11 (Unlawful Assembly) addresses the crime set forth in MCL 752.543. These instructions are entirely new and will take effect on December 1, 2026.

[NEW] M Crim JI 40.9

Riot

(1) The defendant is charged with the crime of riot. To prove this charge, the prosecutor must prove each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

(2) First, that the defendant and four or more other people acted together and with a common purpose to engage in violent conduct.

(3) Second, that when the defendant engaged in violent conduct, [he / she] either intended to place a segment of the public in fear of personal injury or property loss or consciously disregarded a serious risk that [his / her] conduct would place a segment of the public in fear of personal injury or property loss.1

(4) It is not necessary for the prosecution to prove that the defendant personally committed any acts of violence. It is sufficient if the defendant acted in concert with others in furtherance of the group’s wrongful and violent conduct. You may consider a defendant’s presence and conduct at the scene, along with other evidence, to determine whether the defendant shared the common purpose of the group or intended to advance its purpose.2

Use Notes

1. MCL 752.541 requires proof that the defendant “wrongfully engage[d] in violent conduct and thereby intentionally or recklessly cause[d] or create[d] a serious risk of causing public terror or alarm.” The court of appeals has held that a defendant causes “public terror or alarm” whenever “‘a segment of the public is put in fear of injury either to their persons or their property.’” People v Kim, 245 Mich App 609, 615; 630 NW2d 627 (2001) (quoting People v Garcia, 31 Mich App 447, 456; 187 NW2d 711 (1971)).

2. See Garcia, 31 Mich App at 453-454.

[NEW] M Crim JI 40.10

Inciting a Riot

(1) The defendant is charged with the crime of inciting a riot. To prove this charge, the prosecutor must prove each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

(2) First, that the defendant committed one or more of the following acts or urged or encouraged other persons to commit such acts:

[Select from the following according to the charges and evidence:]

(a) an act of unlawful force or violence [or]

(b) the unlawful burning or destruction of property [or]

(c) unlawful interference with a [police officer / peace officer / firefighter / member of the Michigan National Guard / member of the armed services]1

(3) Second, that, by engaging in such conduct, the defendant intended to start or continue a riot.

A riot occurs when five or more persons act together to wrongfully engage in violent conduct with the intent to place a segment of the public in fear of personal injury or property loss or in conscious disregard of a serious risk that a segment of the public would be placed in fear of personal injury or property loss.

Use Note

Include any of the bracketed terms that may apply according to the charges and the evidence.

[NEW] M Crim JI 40.10a

Causing or Conspiring to Cause a Riot in a State Correctional Facility

(1) The defendant is charged with the crime of causing or conspiring to cause a riot in a state correctional facility. To prove this charge, the prosecutor must prove each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

(2) First, that the defendant [provoked / caused / attempted to cause / assisted in causing / conspired to cause]1 a riot at [identify state correctional facility], a state correctional facility in Michigan.

A riot means three or more persons acting together to intentionally or recklessly engage in violent conduct in a state correctional facility that threatens the security of that facility or threatens the safety or authority of persons responsible for maintaining the security of the state correctional facility.

(3) Second, that the defendant did so on purpose, intending to cause a riot at [identify state correctional facility].

Use Note

Include any of the bracketed terms that may apply according to the charges and the evidence.

[NEW] M Crim JI 40.11

Unlawful Assembly

(1) The defendant is charged with the crime of unlawful assembly. To prove this charge, the prosecutor must prove each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

(2) First, that the defendant gathered with four or more other persons or acted together with four or more other persons at [provide location].

(3) Second, that when the defendant gathered or acted together with at least four others there, [he / she] [engaged in a riot / remained when or after a riot developed and intended to help continue the riot].

A riot occurs when five or more persons act together to wrongfully engage in violent conduct with the intent to place a segment of the public in fear of personal injury or property loss or in conscious disregard of a serious risk that a segment of the public would be placed in fear of personal injury or property loss.

The Committee on Model Criminal Jury Instructions has adopted three new instructions on election-related crimes. M Crim JI 43.5 (Election Official Destroying, Falsifying, Altering, or Removing Ballots or Election Records) addresses the crime set forth in MCL 168.932(c). M Crim JI 43.6 (Disclosing Elector’s Vote) and M Crim JI 43.6a (Obstructing an Elector While Attempting to Vote) address the crimes set forth in MCL 168.932(d). These instructions are entirely new and will take effect on December 1, 2026.

[NEW] M Crim JI 43.5

Election Official Destroying, Falsifying, Altering, or Removing Ballots or Election Records

(1) The defendant is charged with the crime of destroying, falsifying, altering, or removing ballots or election records. To prove this charge, the prosecutor must prove each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

(2) First, that the defendant was [a / an / the] [identify election official position]1 for [identify political entity] for the [primary / general / special] election of [provide election date].

(3) Second, that the defendant had custody of the [ballots / (describe election documents alleged)]2 for that election.

(4) Third, that the defendant [destroyed / mutilated / defaced / falsified / removed / hid / altered / erased] all or part of the [ballots / (describe election documents alleged)] or allowed another person to do so.

(5) Fourth, that when the defendant [destroyed / mutilated / defaced / falsified / removed / hid / altered / erased] all or part of the [ballots / (describe election documents alleged)] or allowed another person to do so, [he / she] did so willfully [and with the intent to cheat or deceive]3 rather than by accident or mistake.

Use Notes

1. MCL 168.932(c) describes several election officials: “An inspector of election, clerk, or other officer or person having custody.” Whether the alleged office or position fits within that statutory wording appears to be a question of law for the trial court to resolve. Whether the defendant held that office or position at the time alleged is the question of fact for the jury.

2. MCL 168.932(c) lists several kinds of election documents: “any record, election list of voters, affidavit, return, statement of votes, certificates, poll book, or … any paper, document, or vote of any description, which pursuant to this act is directed to be made, filed, or preserved.” Whether an election document fits within this wording appears to be a question of law for the trial court. Whether the defendant had custody over that document and destroyed, damaged, falsified, or removed it at the time alleged are the questions of fact for the jury.

3. Only some of the acts prohibited by MCL 168.932(c) require an intent to defraud. Accordingly, the bracketed language requiring an intent to cheat or deceive should be read only when it is alleged that the defendant or someone else “fraudulently remove[d] or secrete[d]” election documents or “fraudulently ma[d]e any entry, erasure, or alteration.” See MCL 168.932(c). For purposes of this statute, the term fraudulently means “the specific intent to cheat or deceive.” People v Hawkins, 340 Mich App 155, 175-176; 985 NW2d 853 (2022) (quoting People v Miller, 326 Mich App 719, 739; 929 NW2d 821 (2019)).

[NEW] M Crim JI 43.6

Disclosing Elector’s Vote

(1) The defendant is charged with the crime of disclosing an elector’s vote. To prove this charge, the prosecutor must prove each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

(2) First, that [name targeted elector] was an elector1 who had a right to vote in the [date of election] election.

(3) Second, that [name targeted elector] filled out a ballot to vote in [identify location where the targeted elector voted] in the [date of election] election.

(4) Third, that the defendant saw [name targeted elector]’s ballot.

(5) Fourth, that the defendant told another person who [name targeted elector] voted for.

Use Note

In MCL 168.10 of the Michigan Election Law Act, the phrase qualified elector means “a person who possesses the qualifications of an elector as prescribed in section 1 of article II of the state constitution of 1963 and who has resided in the city or township 30 days.” Mich Const 1963 art 2, §1, defines elector as “[e]very citizen of the United States who has attained the age of 21 years, who has resided in this state six months, and who meets the requirements of local residence provided by law.” US Const amend XXVI, §1, provides, “The right of citizens of the United States, who are eighteen years of age or older, to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of age.” See also MCL 168.492.

[NEW] M Crim JI 43.6a

Obstructing an Elector While Attempting to Vote

(1) The defendant is charged with the crime of obstructing an elector while attempting to vote. To prove this charge, the prosecutor must prove each of the following elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

(2) First, that [name targeted elector] was an elector1 who had a right to vote in the [date of election] election.

(3) Second, that the defendant [obstructed / tried to obstruct] [name targeted elector] from voting or attempting to vote by [describe alleged obstructive conduct].

Use Note

In MCL 168.10 of the Michigan Election Law Act, the phrase qualified elector means “a person who possesses the qualifications of an elector as prescribed in section 1 of article II of the state constitution of 1963 and who has resided in the city or township 30 days.” Mich Const 1963 art 2, §1, defines elector as “[e]very citizen of the United States who has attained the age of 21 years, who has resided in this state six months, and who meets the requirements of local residence provided by law.” US Const amend XXVI, §1, provides, “The right of citizens of the United States, who are eighteen years of age or older, to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of age.” See also MCL 168.492.