Designing and implementing policies to identify conflicts before representation starts is of the utmost importance in legal practice. Once representation has commenced, opportunities to cure a conflict are limited. Under Michigan’s ethical framework, screening is not a general cure for conflicts. The Michigan Rules of Professional Conduct (MRPC) 1.10(b), 1.11, 1.12, and 1.18 permit screening in limited circumstances to isolate a particular lawyer (and sometimes associated nonlawyer personnel)1 from specified matters. Michigan Ethics Opinion R-4 provides that the “conflict screen” segregates the conflicted lawyer from specified matters to prevent imputation of that lawyer’s disqualification to the entire firm.2
MOST CONFLICTS CANNOT BE CURED BY SCREENING
Under MRPC 1.7, a lawyer may not represent a client if the representation is directly adverse to another current client, or if the lawyer’s responsibilities to another client, a third party, or the lawyer’s own interests materially limit the representation. In some circumstances, this can be cured if the client provides informed consent. MRPC 1.7 does not recognize screening as a mechanism to avoid these conflicts. If the representation involves directly adverse interests or a material limitation, the firm must either satisfy the informed-consent requirements or decline or withdraw from the representation. The representation cannot be salvaged by screening.
Conflicts involving former clients are governed by MRPC 1.9. These arise when a lawyer seeks to represent a new client in the same or a substantially related matter that is materially adverse to a former client. In this context, screening is rarely available. Where a lawyer has personally represented a former client in a substantially related matter, that lawyer is disqualified, and under MRPC 1.10, the disqualification is typically imputed to the lawyer’s entire firm. Michigan ethics guidance has consistently emphasized that screening will not cure this type of conflict, particularly where the lawyer had material involvement in the prior matter. The concern is both access to information and the substantial risk that confidential information will be used, consciously or not, against the former client. For that reason, screening is typically not permitted where the matters are substantially related and the lawyer had significant personal involvement in the prior representation. In these circumstances, the conflict is structural, not procedural, and cannot be resolved through internal safeguards.
A PRIMARY EXCEPTION: LAWYERS TRANSITIONING BETWEEN FIRMS
MRPC 1.10, 1.11, and 1.12 are the rules that allow screening a lawyer or former judge who transitions to a new firm. Michigan Ethics Opinion R-4 addresses this situation. The opinion recognizes that when a lawyer who was a principal at the prior firm joins a new firm, the lawyer is rebuttably presumed to have confidential information of the former clients of the prior firm. That presumption, if left unaddressed, may result in imputed disqualification of the new firm under MRPC 1.10.3
R-4 provides a framework for screening to prevent imputation in limited circumstances where the risk of transmission of confidential information can be effectively eliminated through timely and robust screening measures. Even in this context, screening is not an automatic cure. The law firm must establish the screen at the outset of the lawyer’s association with the firm and provide written notice to the tribunal so it may ascertain whether the law firm has taken appropriate measures. R-4 underscores that when the transferring lawyer was a partner or supervising principal, the burden of showing lack of disqualifying confidential information is high, and in some matters, such as long-running institutional client relationships, the need for screening may be effectively indefinite.
Again, this exception is tethered to lawyer mobility and to the specific imputation rule in MRPC 1.10(b). Screening is not a backdoor solution to concurrent conflicts under MRPC 1.7, nor does it rescue a firm from conflicts arising from a lawyer’s own current adverse engagements. If MRPC 1.7 is violated, the representation cannot proceed, as screening is not allowed in this circumstance.
ETHICS OPINION R-4
Michigan Ethics Opinion R-4 outlines the requirements for screening in the lawyer-mobility setting. First, “immediate” screening means putting a full information and fee screen in place the moment the conflicted lawyer joins the new firm, before the lawyer has any contact with conflicted matters.4 In practical terms, the firm must first identify all pending and foreseeable “same or substantially related” matters in which the new lawyer’s former clients are now adverse, and treat the lawyer as personally disqualified from each.5 The lawyer must be excluded from any role in those files, including strategy, supervision, client contact, and informal consultation.
Next, the firm must physically and electronically segregate all related files and information so the screened lawyer cannot access them. That includes moving paper files to a restricted area, limiting electronic permissions, and clearly marking matters as screened. All lawyers and relevant nonlawyer staff must be instructed not to discuss the screened matters in the lawyer’s presence, not to show the lawyer any documents or materials, and not to receive any information from the lawyer about those cases. R-4 also emphasizes that nonlawyer personnel who travel with the lawyer, or who independently move between firms, must be included in the screen, in keeping with MRPC 5.3.
At the same time, the firm must implement fee segregation so that the conflicted lawyer is “apportioned no part of the fee” from those matters, directly or indirectly, through compensation or bonus structures.6 The firm and the lawyer must then promptly send written notice to every affected tribunal describing the screen and fee segregation and provide copies to all other parties to avoid ex parte communication and to allow courts and adversaries to assess compliance. These measures must all be implemented immediately upon the lawyer’s association with the firm. If they are not, R-4 states that the new firm itself is subject to disqualification from continuing or undertaking the affected representations.
PRACTICE-FOCUSED SCREENING TIPS
When a conflicted lawyer joins a firm, R-4 sets forth the requirements to ensure ethical compliance.
Build the screen before day one
The screening process involves identifying all matters that are the same or substantially related in which the lawyer’s former clients are now adverse. Before the lawyer joins the new firm, it is important to determine which of these matters will require a screening measure and to prepare draft notices to tribunals and parties so they can be issued immediately. In the case of lateral principals, there should be a broad presumption that they have had access to confidential information. Firms should take a cautious approach by screening more matters rather than fewer.
Implement a true information wall before the lawyer joins the firm
All screened matters should be carefully flagged in the firm’s case-management and document-management systems, and the lawyer’s access rights to those files should be revoked. Paper files should be physically segregated, such as by placing them in a separate room, locked cabinets, or clearly coded file locations, and prominently labeling them as “SCREENED MATTER – DO NOT DISCUSS WITH [NAME].” In addition, a written, firm-wide memorandum should be distributed to all personnel, including nonlawyer staff, identifying the screened lawyer, the affected matters, and the explicit rules prohibiting any discussion of those matters in the lawyer’s presence, as well as the sharing of documents or receipt of information from the lawyer about those matters. Finally, all affected personnel should be required to acknowledge the memorandum in writing to establish a clear record of notice and understanding.
Exclude the lawyer from all participation
It should be made clear that the lawyer may not supervise lawyers or staff working on screened matters, attend meetings where those matters are discussed, handle client communications, or offer informal “hallway” advice regarding strategy or value. Practice-group or management-committee agendas should also be adjusted so that screened matters are addressed without the lawyer present, either by excluding the lawyer from those portions of meetings or by holding separate sub-meetings. In addition, any inadvertent exposure, such as an email sent in error, should be carefully documented along with an explanation of how it occurred and the remedial steps taken.
Segregate fees in a traceable way
Compensation structures should be modified so that the screened lawyer receives no direct or indirect share of fees from screened matters, including adjustments to origination credit, bonus criteria, and related formulas. The firm should also maintain a clear and auditable record identifying which matters are screened and how the associated fees are excluded from the lawyer’s compensation calculations. These arrangements should be communicated explicitly to the lawyer to ensure there is no expectation of any economic benefit from the screened work.
Give prompt, thorough notice
As soon as the lawyer joins and the screening measures are in place, written notice should be sent to every affected tribunal. The notice should describe, without disclosing confidential information protected by MRPC 1.6, the lawyer’s prior relationship to the adverse party, the matters being screened, the specific screening and fee-segregation measures implemented, and the date the screen became effective. Copies of this notice should also be served on all parties to avoid any ex parte communication and to allow opposing parties to raise objections promptly. The firm should retain a complete file of all notices, acknowledgments, and related correspondence to document the screen in the event its adequacy is later challenged.
Train, monitor, and update
R-4 screening procedures should be incorporated into new-hire orientation and ongoing firm ethics training, with clear emphasis that any violations may result in disqualification of the entire firm. In addition, a conflicts or ethics partner should be designated to oversee the screening process, respond to questions, and periodically verify that all access restrictions and physical safeguards remain properly in place.
CONCLUSION
Michigan’s approach to conflict screening is deliberately narrow. Most conflicts cannot be cured by screening. Instead, conflict screening functions as a targeted tool under MRPC 1.10(b), 1.11, 1.12, 1.18, and Ethics Opinion R-4 to manage imputed disqualification in limited circumstances. Firms that understand this division and that invest in strong front-end screening conflict-check procedures and carefully implemented R-4 walls when lawyer mobility demands it are best positioned to protect client confidences, avoid disqualification, and maintain client trust.