e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 77493
Opinion Date : 05/20/2022
e-Journal Date : 05/24/2022
Court : Michigan Supreme Court
Case Name : Long Lake Twp. v. Maxon
Practice Area(s) : Municipal Constitutional Law
Judge(s) : McCormack, Zahra, Viviano, Bernstein, Clement, Cavanagh, and Welch
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Zoning dispute; Use of a drone to take aerial photos of defendants’ property; The Fourth Amendment; Applicability of the exclusionary rule; Pennsylvania Bd of Probation & Parole v Scott; Kivela v Department of Treasury

Summary

In an order after receiving supplemental briefing, the court vacated its prior order for the scheduling of oral argument and, in lieu of granting leave to appeal, vacated the Court of Appeals judgment (see e-Journal # 75070 in the 3/22/21 edition for the published opinion). It remanded the case to the Court of Appeals “to address the additional issue of whether the exclusionary rule applies to this dispute.” The court noted that the U.S. Supreme Court in Pennsylvania Bd declined “to extend the operation of the exclusionary rule beyond the criminal trial context” and that, in Kivela, the court declined to extend it to a civil tax proceeding.

Full PDF Opinion