e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86080
Opinion Date : 07/10/2026
e-Journal Date : 07/13/2026
Court : Michigan Supreme Court
Case Name : People v. Motten
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Cavanagh, Zahra, Bernstein, Welch, Bolden, and Hood; Not participating – Thomas
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Sentencing; Scoring of OV 3; MCL 777.33(1)(a) & (2)(b); Consideration of acquitted conduct; Applicability of People v Beck

Summary

In an order in lieu of granting leave to appeal, the court vacated the Court of Appeals judgment (see eJournal # 81445 in the 4/22/24 edition for the published opinion) and remanded the case to that court. It directed the Court of Appeals to consider: “(1) whether the jury’s acquittal of defendant on the charge of homicide resolved whether the victim’s death ‘result[ed] from the commission of a crime’”; (2) whether OV 3 was properly scored at 100 points despite defendant’s acquittal on the homicide charge, “given the OV’s use of ‘results’ rather than ‘caused’; and (3) whether” the court’s decision in Beck applied, given that defendant was acquitted of homicide, but convicted of two counts of AWIM for separate victims.

Full PDF Opinion