e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86746
Opinion Date : 10/30/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/16/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : People v. Odem
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Per Curiam - Borrello, Bazzi, and Lievense
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Ineffective assistance of counsel; Failure to investigate & call witnesses; Prejudice; Great weight of the evidence; Alleged recantation; Other acts evidence (prior domestic violence); MCL 768.27b(1); MRE 403; Sentencing; OV 4; MCL 777.34(1)(a); Psychological injury attributable to the sentencing offense; People v Muhammad (Unpub)

Summary

The court held that although trial counsel performed deficiently by failing to investigate potential defense witnesses, defendant failed to establish prejudice. It also held that his convictions were not against the great weight of the evidence, and the prior domestic-violence evidence was admissible, but OV 4 was improperly scored. He was convicted of assault by strangulation and domestic violence after the complainant testified that he strangled her until she could not breathe and later pushed her into a wall, rendering her unconscious. On appeal, the court concluded that counsel’s failure to interview several proposed witnesses “constituted ineffective assistance of counsel,” but the omitted testimony did not create a reasonable probability of a different result. Testimony that the complainant previously acted as the aggressor did not concern the charged incident, while proposed testimony about her statements that defendant had not strangled her was cumulative of evidence already presented through defendant’s half-brother. Medical evidence also documented injuries consistent with strangulation. For similar reasons, the verdict was not against the great weight of the evidence despite the complainant’s purported recantation. The jury heard the recantation evidence along with testimony and photographs showing neck redness and inflammation and “decided that the text message did not negate other testimony regarding the issue of whether the complainant had been strangled.” The court further held that evidence of four prior domestic-violence incidents, three involving strangulation, was properly admitted under MCL 768.27b(1) and MRE 403. The incidents were similar, frequent, and close in time to the charged offense, making an objection futile. But the court agreed that 10 points for OV 4 were improper. The complainant described psychological harm from her relationship with defendant generally, rather than from the sentencing offense specifically. Thus, this case was similar to “Muhammad; ‘there is no specific nexus between the sentencing offense in this case and [the victim’s] general, vague statement regarding PTSD that resulted from years of being assaulted by defendant.’” Because reducing OV 4 to zero altered the guidelines range, the court affirmed the convictions, vacated the sentence, and remanded for resentencing.

Full PDF Opinion