e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86747
Opinion Date : 10/30/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/16/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : In re MDM
Practice Area(s) : Healthcare Law Probate
Judge(s) : Per Curiam – Borrello, Bazzi, and Lievense
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Petition for involuntary mental health treatment; Ineffective assistance of counsel; In re Londowski; Due process; Failure to certify that counsel had seen & consulted with respondent (MCL 330.1454(9)); Distinguishing In re MAT; Requirement to advocate effectively for respondent’s interests; MCR 5.732(B); “Person requiring treatment” (MCL 330.1401(1)(a) & (c)); In re Tchakarova; Principle that only one of the statutory criteria must be satisfied; Hearsay; MRE 1101(b)(10) (authorizing probate courts to consider hearsay information underlying a qualified mental health expert’s opinion)

Summary

The court held that the probate court did not clearly err in determining “that respondent qualified as a person requiring treatment under MCL 330.1401(1)[,]” but it remanded for an evidentiary hearing to develop the record as to his ineffective assistance of counsel claims. The appeal arose from a petition for mental health treatment for respondent. The court began with his ineffective assistance of counsel claims. It found the record showed that his “counsel may have abdicated the fundamental responsibilities of representation guaranteed by the Michigan and United States Constitutions. Counsel’s failure to raise any arguments, present any witnesses, or meaningfully cross-examine those called by the petitioner—beyond the narrow issue of respondent’s alleged noncompliance with the treatment order—may constitute a wholesale forfeiture of advocacy. This potential abdication would not merely be a lapse in trial tactics, but a deprivation that undermines the adversarial process itself. Moreover, counsel’s potential failure to certify that he had seen and consulted with respondent, as explicitly required by MCL 330.1454(9), is not a trivial procedural misstep.” The court concluded that the absence of the certification supported “respondent’s assertion that he was unable to communicate with his attorney, thereby compounding the denial of effective representation.” It found that the “alleged oversights reflect a significant potential failure to advocate effectively for the respondent’s interests, as mandated by MCR 5.732(B).” A full factual record was necessary to determine “whether this was a case of constitutionally ineffective assistance.” But the court rejected respondent’s challenge to the probate court’s determination that he was a person requiring treatment. It held that the “probate court did not err in considering the information underlying” a psychiatrist’s (Dr. H) expert testimony, even if it included hearsay. And it concluded that Dr. H’s uncontradicted testimony satisfied each of MCL 330.1401(1)(c)’s required elements. Affirmed in part and remanded in part.

Full PDF Opinion