e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86749
Opinion Date : 11/02/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/16/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : People v. Hatfield
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Per Curiam - Murray, Boonstra, and Riordan
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Ineffective assistance of counsel; Evidence-tampering instruction; MCL 750.483a(5)(a); M Crim JI 37.11; Knowledge of future official proceeding; People v Walker; Motion to suppress confession; Intoxication; Miranda waiver; People v Soriano; OV 3; MCL 777.33(1)(c); Life-threatening injury

Summary

The court held that defense counsel was not ineffective for failing to object to the then-current standard evidence-tampering instruction, defendant validly waived his Miranda rights despite alcohol consumption, and the trial court properly assessed 25 points for OV 3. He was convicted of AWIGBH, felonious assault, and evidence tampering after cutting the victim’s throat during an altercation and cleaning blood from his home before police arrived. On appeal, defendant argued that the evidence-tampering instruction improperly omitted the requirement that he knew the evidence would be offered in a present or future official proceeding. The court noted that M Crim JI 37.11 was amended in 9/26 to expressly add that element, but defendant’s trial occurred in 2024. At that time, the standard instruction had not been invalidated, and Walker had merely “‘accept[ed]’ without ‘decid[ing]’” that the statute likely included such a knowledge requirement. Critically, “Walker did not go so far as to explain that the standard jury instruction was flawed or otherwise incorrect.” Thus, counsel did not perform deficiently by failing to object to the instruction then in effect. The court also rejected defendant’s challenge to admission of his police statements. Although he had consumed alcohol, the officers testified that he was oriented, responsive, did not slur his speech, and repeatedly indicated that he understood his rights. The trial court found after reviewing the recordings and videos that defendant “certainly had the capacity to, for the minimal purposes here, understand and knowingly waive his rights.” There also was no evidence of police coercion, making the waiver voluntary. Finally, the victim suffered a 10-centimeter neck laceration that clipped an artery, caused substantial blood loss, and required emergency surgery in which the artery was tied off. Because the blood loss and cut artery rendered the injury potentially fatal, the evidence supported the finding that it was life-threatening for purposes of OV 3. Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion