Ineffective assistance of counsel; Expert testimony; MRE 702; Aiding & abetting instruction; Accomplice instructions; M Crim JI 5.4 & 5.6; Prosecutorial error; Sufficiency of the evidence; Felony murder; “Perpetration” of CSC III; People v Gillis; Motion for mistrial; Polygraph reference; Right to present a defense; Closing argument; Cumulative error
The court held that defendant failed to establish ineffective assistance of counsel or prosecutorial error, sufficient evidence supported felony murder, and the challenged trial rulings did not deny him a fair trial. He was convicted of first-degree murder under alternate premeditation and felony murder theories in a 1980 cold case in which the victim was abducted, sexually assaulted, and shot. DNA testing decades later linked defendant and accomplice H to the victim, and H testified about their joint involvement. On appeal, the court rejected defendant’s ineffective-assistance claim arising from a medical examiner’s characterization of the crime as a “sexually-motivated homicide.” Even assuming the testimony was improper, it was not prejudicial because the circumstances already made the sexual nature of the crime apparent and “could not have informed the jury of anything novel or surprising.” Counsel also was not ineffective for failing to object to an aiding-and-abetting instruction because the jury was not required to accept either H’s claim that defendant fired the shots or defendant’s denial of all involvement. Given evidence that both men participated in the abduction and sexual assaults and were present for the murder, “the prosecution was entitled to seek a conviction based on a principal or an aiding-and-abetting theory.” Although counsel should have requested the standard accomplice instructions, there was no reasonable probability of a different result because counsel extensively exposed H’s favorable plea agreement and credibility problems, while DNA and other evidence independently implicated defendant. The prosecutor likewise did not plainly err in eliciting or referring to the medical examiner’s testimony. As to felony murder, the court found “an ‘unbroken chain of events’ between the sexual assault(s), by both defendant and [H], and the eventual murder,” satisfying the perpetration element. The singular, inadvertent reference by the victim’s former boyfriend to passing a polygraph did not require a mistrial where the answer was immediately struck and the jury was twice instructed to disregard it. The court also upheld the restriction on defense closing argument concerning the possible life sentence H had avoided because that fact had not been introduced into evidence. Finally, the cumulative effect of any possible errors did not undermine confidence in the verdict. Affirmed.
Full PDF Opinion