e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86751
Opinion Date : 11/02/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/16/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : People v. Stokes
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Per Curiam - Murray, Boonstra, and Riordan
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Ineffective assistance of counsel; Reference to consent in opening statement without presenting any evidence of consent at trial; Change in trial strategy; Advice in plea negotiations; Sufficiency of the evidence; Identity; CSC I; Unlawful imprisonment; Larceny in a building

Summary

The court held that defense counsel was not ineffective for briefly referring to consent in the opening statement and later pursuing a different defense theory, and that defendant could not show prejudice as to his plea negotiation advice. It also held that sufficient evidence supported defendant’s convictions. He was convicted of two counts of CSC I, unlawful imprisonment, and larceny in a building after the victim testified that defendant forced her into a hotel room at knifepoint, repeatedly sexually assaulted her, stole property, forced her to clean the room, and tied her arms and legs before leaving. On appeal, defendant argued that counsel undermined the defense by initially stating that the case involved consent but presenting no consent evidence. The court disagreed. Viewed as a whole, counsel’s opening focused primarily on the victim’s credibility and whether the physical evidence corroborated her account. Cross-examination and closing argument pursued that same theory. Further, even if counsel initially intended to pursue consent, changing strategies after hearing the victim’s testimony was reasonable. A consent theory would have conceded defendant’s presence and sexual contact in the room, while the lack of DNA and fingerprint evidence permitted counsel to challenge whether defendant was there at all. “By shifting the defense from consent, defense counsel used the inconsistencies in the victim’s testimony and the lack of forensic evidence to argue that the prosecution did not meet its burden of proof.” As to sufficiency, the court emphasized that “‘a complainant’s testimony regarding a defendant’s commission of sexual acts is sufficient evidence to support a conviction for’” CSC I. Her testimony also established the restraint necessary for unlawful imprisonment and the taking of property necessary for larceny in a building. Moreover, the record contained corroboration. Police recovered a serrated knife consistent with her description, observed marks on her arms and ankles consistent with being bound, obtained surveillance footage of a person matching defendant’s description, and the victim identified defendant in a photographic array. Thus, sufficient evidence established his identity as the perpetrator and supported each conviction. Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion