Resentencing after remand; Scope of remand; De novo resentencing; Presentence posture; Challenges to OV scoring; People v Lampe; Request for reassignment to a different judge; People v Hill
The court held that the trial court erred by treating the prior remand for resentencing as limited to providing defendant an uninterrupted opportunity for allocution, but resentencing before a different judge was not required. Defendant was convicted of delivery or manufacture of meth, evidence tampering, maintaining a drug house, and resisting or obstructing police. In the first appeal, the court vacated his sentences because the trial court repeatedly interrupted his allocution and remanded “for resentencing with a full opportunity for allocution.” On remand, defendant challenged OVs 13 and 19, but the trial court ruled those challenges were beyond the scope of the remand and limited the proceeding to allocution before reimposing the same sentences. On appeal, the court concluded that this interpretation was erroneous. As in Lampe, “[b]y ordering ‘resentencing’ without any specific instructions or any prohibitions on scoring OVs, this Court returned the case to the trial court in a presentence posture, allowing the trial court to consider every aspect of defendant’s sentences de novo.” Although the prior opinion specifically identified the allocution error, it vacated the entire sentence and did not restrict the issues that could be considered at resentencing. Thus, “when a case is remanded for resentencing without specific prohibitions, the parties are placed in a presentence posture, permitting a de novo view of the defendant’s sentencing.” Thus, he may raise the OV challenges and other sentencing issues identified in his resentencing memorandum. But the court declined to order reassignment. Although this was the second sentencing error requiring remand, the trial judge complied with the earlier directive to permit meaningful allocution, her interpretation of the remand was incorrect but not unreasonable, and nothing suggested frustration, animosity, or bias. Reassignment also would create unnecessary duplication because the existing judge was familiar with the case. The court vacated defendant’s sentences and remanded for de novo resentencing before the same judge.
Full PDF Opinion