Regulatory & physical taking; Takings Clauses; Inverse condemnation; Public nuisance; Airport hazard; MCL 259.441; MCL 259.443; Timber trespass; MCL 600.2919(1)(a); Governmental immunity; Governmental Tort Liability Act (GTLA); MCL 691.1407(1); Governmental function
The court held that plaintiff-Airport Authority’s enforcement of an airport-hazard height restriction and removal of trees constituting a public nuisance did not amount to a compensable taking, and governmental immunity barred defendant-property owner’s timber-trespass claim. Defendant owned wooded property near Metro Airport that was subject to an airport zoning ordinance limiting trees to 50 feet above the airport’s elevation. Plaintiff sued defendant asserting a public nuisance; she counterclaimed. The parties stipulated that several trees exceeded that limit, and defendant alleged plaintiff’s employees entered her property and removed or trimmed trees without permission. On appeal, defendant argued that the ordinance and tree removal constituted a physical or regulatory taking. The court rejected the claim because the overheight trees constituted a public nuisance. It explained that “‘because no individual has the right to use his or her property so as to create a nuisance, the State has not taken anything when it asserts its power to enjoin a nuisance-like activity.’” The airport-zoning statute independently provides that maintaining an airport hazard is “a public nuisance and an injury to the community served by the airport.” Thus, because defendant allowed trees to exceed the ordinance’s safety-based height restriction, “plaintiff did not take defendant’s property by enacting the ordinance height limit or by cutting down trees on her property.” Her separate contention that plaintiff blocked access to the property also failed because the record established that the Wayne County Roads Division, not plaintiff, closed the road, and she produced no evidence plaintiff itself blocked access. The court further rejected her timber-trespass claim. The GTLA immunizes a governmental agency engaged in a governmental function, and state law expressly authorizes political subdivisions to regulate tree heights in airport-hazard areas. Because plaintiff’s enforcement actions were “authorized by both ordinance and statute, plaintiff was engaged in a governmental function when it cut down trees on defendant’s property.” Defendant identified no applicable immunity exception. Affirmed.
Full PDF Opinion