Governmental immunity; Governmental Tort Liability Act (GTLA); Gross negligence; MCL 691.1407(2); Duty; Special relationship; Proximate cause; Proprietary function exception; MCL 691.1413; Nuisance & premises liability; Recreational Land Use Act (RUA); MCL 324.73301
The court held that plaintiff’s claims against the individual city defendants did not overcome governmental immunity because the allegations failed to establish a duty, gross negligence, or proximate causation, but a factual question remained as to whether the proprietary function exception applied to his nuisance and premises-liability claims against defendant-City. Plaintiff’s 19-year-old son drowned while swimming in Lake Michigan at a city-operated park on a day when federal weather agencies warned of dangerous waves and currents. Plaintiff alleged several city officials and employees were grossly negligent for failing to close the beach despite those warnings. On appeal, the court first concluded that the individual defendants owed no common-law duty to the decedent. There was no special relationship because he and his friends had no contact with the officials and did not entrust themselves to their protection. Rather, the decedent “entered the water of his own volition,” and the court determined that “it is too heavy a burden to impose an affirmative duty on city officials to ensure the survival of individuals who choose to enter the water on their own volition despite a warning system advising them of a high risk due to heavy currents.” The alleged conduct also did not constitute gross negligence. The city had installed a warning-light system, assigned an officer to beach patrol, and posted weather and lake information. Those measures “contradict a finding that any defendant exhibited ‘conduct so reckless as to demonstrate a substantial lack of concern for whether an injury results.’” Further, the failure to close the beach was not “the most immediate, efficient, and direct cause” of the drowning because defendants did not cause the decedent to enter the water and “at best, defendants merely failed to prevent it from happening.” But summary disposition was premature as to the claims against the City. Plaintiff alleged substantial parking revenue from the park, while the City’s financial materials did not establish the park’s operating costs or otherwise foreclose the proprietary function exception as a matter of law. Thus, plaintiff was entitled to discovery on that issue. The RUA also did not bar the claims because it “‘does not apply to public property.’” Affirmed as to the individual defendants, vacated and reversed as to the City, and remanded.
Full PDF Opinion