e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86756
Opinion Date : 11/05/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/17/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : People v. Hill
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Per Curiam – Young, Redford, and Feeney
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Ineffective assistance of counsel; Probable cause for bindover; People v Burkman; Futile motion; Failure to investigate cell phone location data; Sentencing; Notice of a fourth-offense habitual offender enhancement; MCL 769.13; MCR 6.112(F); People v Head

Summary

In consolidated appeals, the court rejected defendant-Hill’s ineffective assistance of counsel claims and concluded that he received timely notice of the prosecution’s intent to charge him as a fourth-offense habitual offender. Thus, it affirmed his armed robbery convictions and his concurrent sentences, as a fourth-offense habitual offender, of 25 to 50 years. He first contended that defense counsel was ineffective for failing to argue that the evidence at the preliminary exams “was insufficient to establish probable cause that he was the armed robber.” But the court noted that defense counsel argued “that there was insufficient evidence to support the bindovers; counsel cannot be ineffective for failing to do that which was done.” It also rejected Hill’s claim “that defense counsel should have moved to quash the bindover orders in the circuit court.” The preliminary exam evidence “connected Hill with the robberies through [his] use of the Impala, including Hill being arrested while driving the Impala shortly after it was used in the Walgreens robbery. Although Hill suggested that the Impala was being driven by a person named ‘Cheese’ as a type of short-term rental, the fact that the driver of the Impala used Hill’s Speedway rewards card immediately after the Walgreens robbery provides a reasonable inference that Hill was, in fact, the driver and robber. Although circumstantial, this evidence was sufficient to ‘cause a person of ordinary prudence and caution to conscientiously entertain a reasonable belief in defendant’s guilt.’” Thus, the court held that the district courts did not abuse their discretion in binding him over; “a motion to quash would have been futile and defense counsel cannot be ineffective for failing to make a futile motion.” As to his claim for failing to reasonably investigate his cell phone location data, the record established that this “data would not have helped Hill.” Finally, as to the habitual-offender notice, he “could not have been arraigned on any information earlier than the conclusion of the preliminary” exam on 1/25/23. Because all the mislabeled “amended” informations were filed by 21 days after that date, the court concluded that he received timely notice in each case.

Full PDF Opinion