Trespass & nuisance in fact; Failure to file trial exhibits; MCR 7.210(C); Noneconomic damages; Mack v Natural Way, Inc; Economic damages; Causation; Comparative negligence; Adverse possession; Tacking; Nuisance abatement
The court held that plaintiff established trespass and nuisance in fact arising from defendant’s concentrated water drainage, that noneconomic damages were unavailable for trespass but recoverable for nuisance, and that the economic-damages and abatement awards required modification. Defendant’s adverse-possession counterclaim failed. Plaintiff owned residential property adjoining defendant’s commercial property. She alleged defendant modified its downspouts and drainage system so that collector pipes concentrated runoff onto her land, causing years of flooding and substantial damage. After a bench trial, the trial court awarded economic and noneconomic damages and ordered nuisance abatement. On appeal, the court first noted that defendant failed to file the trial exhibits as required by MCR 7.210(C) and could not benefit from that omission. As to noneconomic damages, binding precedent established that “plaintiff’s cause of action for trespass does not support the trial court’s award of noneconomic damages.” But nuisance protects an owner’s use and enjoyment of property, and evidence showed plaintiff endured nearly seven years of interference, exhaustion, and emotional distress. Thus, “the trial court’s award of noneconomic damages under plaintiff’s nuisance in fact cause of action was not clearly erroneous.” The court also upheld causation as to the economic damages, finding the evidence “sufficient to demonstrate that focused excessive water drainage from the 1300 Property onto the 1324 Property was a cause of the resultant damages plaintiff suffered.” But the trial court clearly erred in calculating economic damages because it mistakenly treated testimony that up to $65,000 was spent repairing the house as a separate amount for the garage, with the result that its “award effectively awards those amounts twice.” The supported economic award was $65,000, reduced by 20% comparative negligence to $52,000. Defendant also failed to establish adverse possession because it offered insufficient proof permitting it to tack the prior owner’s possession onto its own and could not establish the 15-year period. Finally, nuisance abatement remained proper only to the extent the retaining wall continued to encroach on plaintiff’s property. Affirmed in part, reversed in part, vacated in part, and remanded for entry of an amended judgment.
Full PDF Opinion