Sufficiency of the evidence for an AWIGBH conviction; Intent; People v Harrington; Right to present a defense; Denial of midtrial motion to add a witness to the defense witness list; Cumulative testimony; MRE 403; Ineffective assistance of counsel; Failure to move to quash; Prejudice; MCR 6.110(F) & (H); Failure to question a juror during voir dire & to remove that juror; People v Unger
The court held that the evidence of defendant’s intent was sufficient to support her AWIGBH conviction as to one of the victims (W), and it rejected her ineffective assistance of counsel claims. Further, she was not denied her right to present a defense by the trial court’s denial of her midtrial motion to add W to the defense witness list. Thus, the court affirmed her AWIGBH and felony-firearm convictions. She asserted “there was no evidence that she intended to cause ‘serious injury of an aggravated nature’ to [W], emphasizing that she missed [W’s] face and struck only [W’s] shoulder, did not try to strike [W] again, and caused no injury requiring treatment.” However, the question was “not what injury defendant caused, but what injury she intended.” The court found that, viewed “in the light most favorable to the prosecution, the evidence showed that defendant had just attacked [the other victim], leaving her on the ground with portions of her hair torn from her scalp. Defendant then turned on [W] while holding a handgun, threatened to ‘pistol whip’ her, and swung the gun at her head. Surveillance footage” corroborated the victims’ accounts and “allowed the jury to see the force and manner of that swing for itself. The jury could reasonably conclude that defendant intended to cause serious injury of an aggravated nature to” W when she tried to strike her “in the head with a handgun. That [she] missed her target because [W] moved does not negate her intent when she swung.” As to her request to recall W as a defense witness, this “would have produced the same testimony the jury had already heard.” The court concluded that the trial “court’s decision to exclude needlessly cumulative testimony fell within the range of principled outcomes.” Her claim that defense counsel was ineffective for failing to challenge the bindover as to W failed for lack of prejudice. “Nothing in the record suggests that the prosecution could not have refiled the charges and presented additional evidence at a new preliminary” exam. She also did “not overcome the strong presumption that counsel’s decision to keep Juror One was strategic” and she could not “establish prejudice because nothing in the record shows that Juror One was actually biased.”
Full PDF Opinion