e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86759
Opinion Date : 11/05/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/17/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : People v. Coverdale
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Per Curiam - Ackerman, Borrello, and Korobkin
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Third-offense domestic violence; Sentence enhancement; MCL 750.81(5); Applicability of MCL 750.81b; Defective enhancement notice; Amendment of information or notice; MCR 6.112(H); Plea agreement; Prosecutorial charging authority; Withdrawal from plea agreement

Summary

The court held that the trial court erred by treating an error in defendant’s third-offense domestic-violence notice as foreclosing the enhancement and by sentencing him for a lesser offense while retaining the prosecution’s concessions under the plea agreement. He pled guilty to felony third-offense domestic violence and attempted resisting or obstructing a police officer pursuant to an agreement under which the prosecution dismissed or reduced other charges and habitual-offender enhancements. Before sentencing, the prosecution discovered that one of the two prior domestic-violence convictions listed in the third-offense notice did not exist, but identified another qualifying 2019 conviction. The trial court found the notice defective and sentenced defendant for misdemeanor second-offense domestic violence. On appeal, the court declined to decide whether MCL 750.81b applies to enhancements under MCL 750.81(5), concluding that even if it did, the defect was curable by amendment under MCR 6.112(H). Substituting the 2019 conviction would not have increased the enhancement or maximum sentence, defendant received the supporting documentation more than a month before sentencing, and he did not dispute the conviction’s accuracy. “Nothing in the court rules or in MCL 750.81b provides that an error in the identification of prior convictions permanently forecloses an enhancement that the prosecution has properly noticed and proved.” Thus, the prosecution was “entitled to amend the notice to substitute the 2019 conviction.” The court further concluded that even if the enhancement were unavailable, “[h]aving concluded that the third-offense enhancement was unavailable, the trial court could not sentence defendant for a lesser offense while holding the prosecution to the concessions made in exchange for defendant’s plea to a greater offense.” Rather, the prosecution had to be permitted to withdraw from the agreement. The trial court “was not permitted to impose on the prosecution a bargain to which the prosecution had not agreed.” The court vacated the judgment of sentence in the domestic-violence case and remanded.

Full PDF Opinion