e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86760
Opinion Date : 11/05/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/17/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : Essa v. Michigan Auto. Ins. Placement Facility
Practice Area(s) : Insurance
Judge(s) : Per Curiam – Ackerman, Borrello, and Korobkin
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

No-fault insurance priority dispute; PIP benefits; Policy rescission; Change in position; The “mend the hold” doctrine; Smith v Grange Mut Fire Ins Co of MI; Whether policy application inaccuracies provided a lawful basis for rescission; Innocent misrepresentation; Titan Ins Co v Hyten; Effect of signing the application; Balancing the equities; Pioneer State Mut Ins Co v Wright

Summary

The court held that the “mend the hold” doctrine did not preclude defendant-insurer (Progressive) from rescinding the no-fault policy it issued to plaintiff’s husband, and that the policy application’s inaccuracies provided a lawful basis for rescission. Further, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in balancing the equities and granting Progressive rescission. After plaintiff and her husband (D) were involved in an auto accident, Progressive denied her claim for PIP benefits. She then sued defendant-MAIPF, and later amended her complaint to add Progressive. On appeal, MAIPF argued “that Progressive should be precluded from rescinding the” policy because material misrepresentation, its basis for seeking rescission, “was not the reason it initially gave for denying plaintiff’s claim.” MAIPF asserted that Progressive’s change of position violated the “mend the hold” doctrine. The court concluded that Progressive’s initial “denial on the basis of plaintiff not being a resident relative under the policy does not bar it from seeking rescission on the facts presented here. Under Smith, an insurer must ‘fully apprise the insured of all the defenses it intends to rely upon, and its failure to do so is, in legal effect, a waiver, and estops it from maintaining any defenses to an action on the policy other than those of which it has thus given notice.’ But when Progressive denied plaintiff’s claim, it had not been informed that [D] was married to plaintiff or that he and his family resided” with plaintiff and her daughters (his application listed an address in another city). The court found that the “trial court properly did not treat ‘mend the hold’ as an obstacle to granting rescission.” As to a lawful basis for rescission, the court held that all “six elements of the innocent misrepresentation test” were satisfied. As to balancing the equities, the first and fourth factors were at issue. The court concluded that, if “anything, the trial court should have found that the first factor weighed in favor of rescission.” The fourth factor was dispositive. The trial court did not abuse its discretion in considering that “rescission would allow plaintiff to avoid any complications caused by the one-year-back rule,” or by not addressing “the impact of the $250,000 cap” under MCL 500.3172(7)(a) on plaintiff’s ability to recover benefits. Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion