e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86761
Opinion Date : 11/06/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/18/2026
Court : U.S. Court of Appeals Sixth Circuit
Case Name : United States v. Cook
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Thapar and Hermandorfer; Concurring in part & in the the judgment – Moore
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Search-warrant affidavit; Franks v Delaware hearing; Intentional or reckless falsehood; Evidence outside the affidavit; Ineffective assistance of counsel claim on direct appeal; Sentencing; Acceptance of responsibility; USSG § 3E1.1(a); Career-offender enhancement; USSG § 4B1.1; Procedural & substantive reasonableness; 18 USC § 3553(a); Confidential informant (CI)

Summary

The court held that the district court did not err in denying defendant a Franks hearing, declined to consider his ineffective assistance of counsel claim on direct appeal, and concluded his substantially below-Guidelines sentence was neither procedurally nor substantively unreasonable. After officers observed two controlled drug buys outside defendant’s home, they obtained a search warrant and found drugs, firearms, ammunition, and drug-trafficking materials. He ultimately pled guilty to several drug and firearm offenses and received a 248-month sentence, 112 months below the bottom of his Guidelines range. On appeal, he argued that statements in the warrant affidavit concerning surveillance of his back door and the CI’s identification of him were false. The court concluded that he failed to make the substantial preliminary showing of a knowing, intentional, or reckless falsehood necessary for a Franks hearing. The photos he offered did not establish that officers could not see the rear of the house because “[t]he affidavit made clear that multiple officers were surveilling the house during each drug deal,” and police reports confirmed that an officer was positioned on a golf course behind the house during one controlled buy. The court also rejected defendant’s contention that the government could not rely on evidence outside the warrant affidavit at this preliminary stage, reasoning that “judges should have the whole picture before them in order to see whether an evidentiary hearing is appropriate.” His second claimed falsehood likewise failed because the affidavit only stated that the CI identified defendant’s photo as the person known as “‘JR.’ There’s not even a hint of falsehood here.” As to ineffective assistance, the court declined direct review because “the record doesn’t plainly show ineffective lawyering” and did not reveal why prior counsel declined to pursue the Franks arguments. As to sentencing, the district court properly denied an acceptance-of-responsibility reduction where defendant operated a drug-trafficking scheme while incarcerated and was caught smuggling drugs on the day he pled guilty. The court noted, it has “‘repeatedly upheld decisions denying the acceptance-of-responsibility reduction to defendants who engaged in conduct similar to the offense of conviction while awaiting the entry of a plea or sentencing.’” The career-offender enhancement was also properly applied, resulting in a Guidelines range of 360 months to life. Finally, defendant failed to show that the 248-month sentence was substantively unreasonable where the district court considered his personal history, addiction, sentencing disparities, lengthy criminal record, continued drug activity, and need for deterrence and public protection. “In short, there’s no sign that the court improperly weighed the § 3553(a) factors.” Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion