Motion for relief from judgment; Cruel or unusual punishment; Const 1963, art 1, § 16; Parolable life sentences for offenses committed at age 18; People v Sykes; People v Eads; Stare decisis; MCR 7.215(J)(1); People v Bullock factors
The court held that defendant failed to establish that his discretionary, parolable life sentences for second-degree murder and AWIM committed when he was 18 years old constituted cruel or unusual punishment under the Michigan Constitution. He sought relief from judgment based on recent decisions addressing the constitutionality of severe sentences imposed on youthful offenders. On appeal, the court concluded that it remained bound by Sykes, which held that a parolable life sentence for second-degree murder committed by a 20-year-old did not violate Const 1963, art 1, § 16. Although the Supreme Court subsequently decided Eads, which held that a 50-to-75-year sentence for second-degree murder committed by a youthful offender was unconstitutional, the court emphasized that “Eads did not explicitly overrule Sykes.” The cases also involved materially different circumstances. Eads concerned a 16-year-old serving a term-of-years sentence, while defendant was 18 and received discretionary parolable life sentences. Thus, because Eads “did not clearly modify Sykes’s holding as it pertained to a parolable life sentence for an adult convicted of second-degree murder committed before the age of 21, this Court remains bound by Sykes.” The court also rejected defendant’s reliance on the Bullock factors. As in Sykes, the record contained insufficient evidence regarding sentences imposed in other jurisdictions, including whether adults under 21 receive parolable life sentences and how other jurisdictions administer parole. The court ultimately found “no facts or evidence upon which we might reasonably conclude that MCL 750.317 or MCL 750.83 constitute cruel or unusual punishment insofar as they authorize the imposition of defendant’s non-mandatory, parolable life sentences.” Affirmed.
Full PDF Opinion