Sentencing; Proportionality & reasonableness; People v Lampe; Effect of a within-guidelines sentence; People v Posey; “Unusual circumstances”; People v Bowling
Holding that defendant failed “to overcome the presumption that his within-guidelines sentence” was proportionate, the court concluded that the trial court sentenced him “to a proportionate and reasonable” sentence. He was convicted of delivery of meth and marijuana. He was originally sentenced as a fourth-offense habitual offender and a drug subsequent offender to concurrent terms of 15 to 40 years for the meth conviction and 2 to 8 years for the marijuana conviction. After the correction of an error as to his criminal history, the trial court resentenced him to concurrent terms of 10 to 40 years for the meth conviction and 2 to 8 years for the marijuana conviction. On appeal, the court found the record did not support his claim “that the trial court failed to meaningfully engage with the individual facts of” the case. Its reliance on the “guidelines satisfied the articulation requirement.” And while defendant asserted “that his institutional record, articulation of remorse, and comparative culpability are unusual, he” did not further articulate this argument and failed “to establish unusual circumstances that would have rendered his presumptively proportionate sentence disproportionate.” The court noted that his comments at resentencing supported “that the trial court considered his conduct while in custody and his expression of remorse.” Its statements at resentencing showed “that it thoroughly considered the circumstances of the offense and the applicable guidelines range to determine an appropriate penalty. [It] explicitly stated that it was considering the matter anew given that defendant erroneously had a cocaine conviction attributed to him. [It] reviewed briefs, considered the seriousness of the offense, and highlighted the judiciary’s role in protecting the public and community. Even though [it] made side comments about a ‘separate case,’ [it] also said that it was ‘not attributing any of that to [defendant]’ and made clear that it was ‘just commenting on the general malaise’ and drug culture in Benton Harbor. Recognizing that drug culture and drug trafficking contributed to ‘the general degradation of the community,’ the trial court stressed that the purpose of imposing its within-guidelines sentence was punishment, protection of the community, deterrence, reformation, and restitution.”
Full PDF Opinion