e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86766
Opinion Date : 11/06/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/18/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : Williams v. City of Detroit
Practice Area(s) : Municipal Negligence & Intentional Tort
Judge(s) : Per Curiam - Lievense, Swartzle, and Mariani
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Premises liability; Governmental immunity; Governmental Tort Liability Act (GTLA); Sidewalk exception; MCL 691.1402a; Statutory presumption of reasonable repair; Dangerous sidewalk condition other than vertical discontinuity; MCL 691.1402a(3)(b); Actual or constructive notice; 30-day requirement

Summary

The court held that plaintiff presented sufficient evidence to rebut the statutory presumption that defendant-City maintained the sidewalk in reasonable repair and to create a factual question as to whether it had the required notice of the defect. Plaintiff was injured when he stepped onto a curb adjoining a city sidewalk and loose pavement crumbled beneath his foot. In a prior appeal, the court determined that the curb was part of the sidewalk and remanded for consideration of governmental immunity under MCL 691.1402a. On appeal following remand, the City argued that plaintiff could not rebut the statutory presumption of reasonable repair because he had not established a vertical discontinuity of two inches or more. The court rejected that argument because the statute permits rebuttal by establishing either such a discontinuity or “a dangerous condition in the sidewalk itself of a particular character other than solely a vertical discontinuity.” Plaintiff relied on the latter provision. His deposition described a gap containing loose pavement, a 2019 city survey identified broken sidewalk slabs requiring repair, Google Street View images showed a crack in the relevant location, and a photograph taken shortly after the accident depicted the resulting gouge. “Taken together, these allegations and evidence adequately show as a legal matter that the sidewalk was in a ‘dangerous condition . . . of a particular character other than solely a vertical discontinuity.’” The court likewise rejected the City’s notice argument. The 2019 survey and photographs indicated that the sidewalk was already broken years before plaintiff’s fall, a city engineering coordinator confirmed that the City had identified the broken slabs, and there was evidence they were never repaired. Thus, “a jury could reasonably conclude that defendant had actual or constructive notice that the sidewalk was in a dangerous condition more than 30 days before his fall” because it was already damaged in 2019, deteriorated over time, and remained unrepaired. Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion