Res judicata; Whether an order denying leave to amend was a decision on the merits; Martin v Michigan Consol Gas Co; Futility basis; Final judgment; Involuntary dismissal under Fed R Civ P 41(b); Challenges to the federal court’s authority to enter the order in a related federal case; Jurisdiction; Amount in controversy; Notice of voluntary dismissal; Judicial bias; Dismissal due to another pending action (MCR 2.116(C)(6)); Alternative ground for summary disposition under MCR 2.116(C)(7); Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)
Holding that res judicata barred plaintiff’s ADA and breach of contract claims in this fifth lawsuit arising from defendants-attorney and law firm’s prior representation of plaintiff, the court affirmed summary disposition for defendants. She retained the law firm in 2021 to represent her in appeals. While her third lawsuit against them was pending in federal court, she filed this one. In the federal case she alleged a breach of contract claim and, after defendants answered, she moved to amend her complaint to add claims under Title III of the ADA. In a 7/24 order, the federal district court denied her motion as futile. In this case, she alleged breach of the retainer agreement and discrimination in violation of Title III of the ADA. The trial court granted defendants summary disposition of the ADA claim based on res judicata. On appeal, the court found that the question was whether the 7/24 “order was a decision on the merits of plaintiff’s ADA claim.” It concluded that the order fell “squarely within Martin.” The federal district court “denied leave to amend solely on the basis of futility. It reasoned in part that Title III of the ADA does not provide for monetary damages in a suit brought by a private plaintiff,” and this constituted “a determination that plaintiff’s claim for damages under Title III was ‘legally insufficient on [its] face.’” Thus, the order “adjudicated, on the merits, precisely the claim that plaintiff asserts here.” In addition, by “the time the trial court ruled on [6/20/25], the consolidated federal action had proceeded to final judgment: the federal court dismissed that action with prejudice” 10 days earlier. Plaintiff’s appellate arguments challenged “the federal court’s authority to enter the [7/24] order, such that the order cannot be given preclusive effect.” The court found no merit in those challenges. As to her contract breach claim, while the trial court granted defendants summary disposition under MCR 2.116(C)(6), that provision no longer supplied a basis for doing so when the trial court issued its ruling. But the court held that reversal was not warranted because the federal “judgment that removed the predicate for summary disposition under MCR 2.116(C)(6) supplies an independent ground for affirmance under (C)(7)” based on res judicata. The contract breach “claim in this case was resolved in the consolidated federal action.”
Full PDF Opinion