Other acts evidence; MCL 768.27b; People v Berklund; MRE 403; People v Watkins; Sufficiency of the evidence for an unlawful imprisonment conviction (MCL 750.349b); “Restrain” (MCL 750.349b(3)(a)); People v Chelmicki; Ineffective assistance of counsel; Failure to request a self-defense jury instruction; M Crim JI 7.22; Lack of evidence to support an instruction; Futile request; Trial strategy; Failure to preserve objections to the victim testifying via Zoom; MCR 6.006; People v Jemison; Prejudice
The court held that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting evidence of other incidents under MCL 768.27b, and that there was sufficient evidence to support defendant’s unlawful imprisonment conviction. It also rejected his claims that defense counsel was ineffective for failing to request a self-defense jury instruction and preserve objections to the victim testifying via Zoom. He was also convicted of domestic violence and assault by strangulation. The court noted that “evidence of other acts of domestic violence is probative because it makes it more likely that the defendant committed an act of domestic violence for which” defendant is charged. It addressed all six Watkins factors. Considering “the similarities and differences between the other-acts evidence and the charged offenses, the first Watkins factor appears neutral.” Next, the court found that, “because there is no bar under MCL 768.27b on considering other acts of domestic violence that postdate the charged conduct and the [7/24] incidents occurred quite closely in time to the [5/24] incident for which defendant was charged” the second factor favored admission. The court concluded that the “third factor, the infrequency of the other acts, does not support excluding the evidence given defendant’s commission of three additional acts of domestic violence.” It also saw no “relevant intervening acts under the fourth factor. And the fifth factor, the lack of reliability of the evidence supporting the occurrence of the other acts,” favored admission because the 7/24 incidents were on video, a detective testified as to the content of the “videos at trial, and there is no dispute that this evidence accurately portrayed” the incidents. As to the sixth factor, the “incidents bolstered the likelihood that defendant committed the charged offenses” despite the victim’s trial testimony that she still loved him, “that she did not want to have to testify, and that she had wanted the matter to be dismissed. In sum, applying the Watkins factors generally indicates that the evidence of the [7/24] incidents was quite probative.” And there was no indication that it “injected extraneous conditions designed to arouse bias, sympathy, or shock among the jurors, nor that it stirred such passion in the jury as to ‘divert [it] from rational consideration of defendant’s guilt or innocence of the charged offenses.’” Affirmed.
Full PDF Opinion