e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86771
Opinion Date : 11/09/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/19/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : People v. Mack
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Per Curiam - Swartzle, Ackerman, and Trebilcock
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Miranda right to counsel; Edwards v Arizona; Reinitiation of custodial interrogation; People v Fenderson; Knowing, intelligent & voluntary waiver; People v Cipriano; Juror challenges for cause; MCR 2.511(E)(10); Prior prosecution by prosecuting attorney’s office; People v Eccles

Summary

The court held that defendant validly reinitiated communication with police and voluntarily waived his Miranda right to counsel after invoking it, and that the trial court was required to excuse prospective jurors who previously had been prosecuted by the same prosecutor’s office. He was convicted of first-degree premeditated murder and firearm offenses. During custodial interrogation, defendant initially waived his rights but later unequivocally requested an attorney. Detectives stopped the interrogation and began leaving, after which defendant asked what they wanted to discuss, stated that he could “talk all day long,” and agreed to continue without counsel. On appeal, the court held that these statements reflected “several ‘affirmative request[s] to reinitiate the interrogation without an attorney’ and ‘an expression of willingness to talk generally about the investigation without counsel.’” It rejected defendant’s assertion that the detectives improperly pressured him after his invocation. Police are not prohibited from all communication following a request for counsel, and the brief exchanges here constituted “careful police work, not unconstitutional pressure placed on defendant to continue to custodial interrogation.” The totality of the circumstances also supported a voluntary waiver. Defendant was coherent, had significant prior experience with police, received food and water, was not threatened or physically mistreated, and no detective suggested he would receive leniency by continuing the interview. As to jury selection, defendant challenged the dismissal for cause of six prospective jurors who previously had been prosecuted by the county Prosecutor’s Office. Binding precedent foreclosed his argument. Under MCR 2.511(E)(10) and Eccles, once a prospective juror falls within the provision, “‘the trial court is without discretion to retain that juror, who must be excused for cause,’” regardless of whether the juror claims an ability to remain impartial. Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion