e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86772
Opinion Date : 11/09/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/19/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : Auro Rehab Servs LLC v. Auto-Owners Ins. Co.
Practice Area(s) : Litigation
Judge(s) : Per Curiam – Ackerman, Borrello, and Korobkin
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Dismissal discovery sanction; MCR 2.313(B)(2)(c); Vicencio v Ramirez; Kalamazoo Oil Co v Boerman

Summary

Holding that the trial court abused its discretion in dismissing plaintiff’s action with prejudice as a discovery sanction, the court vacated the trial court’s order and remanded. The court noted that dismissal “‘is a drastic step that should be taken cautiously.’” It set forth seven relevant factors to consider in Vicencio. “In dismissing the action, the trial court did not engage with the relevant factors, did not consider any other available options on the record, and did not explain why it deemed dismissal the just and proper sanction in this case.” In the absence of such reasoning, the court was “unable to conduct a meaningful review of the trial court’s decision on appeal. When a trial court fails to conduct the required on-the-record analysis, the proper course is to vacate and remand for the trial court to consider the relevant factors and other available options.” The court stated that, on “remand, should the trial court conclude that dismissal is just and proper, [it] must explain its rationale, including its consideration of other available options, so as to facilitate meaningful appellate review.” The court noted that it did not decide here “that sanctions were unwarranted. The record appears to support defendant’s allegations that plaintiff violated the court rules by failing to timely disclose and produce relevant records, to otherwise respond to discovery requests, and to supplement its responses.” But defendant failed to “identify any court orders that plaintiff directly violated, plaintiff did produce some records and witnesses for deposition, and plaintiff agreed that it would provide additional records and allow witnesses to be redeposed. The required sanction for failing to respond to a motion or appear for a hearing on a motion is costs, not dismissal.” Further, the record did not show “that the trial court considered whether a sanction less drastic than dismissal with prejudice would serve the interests of justice.”

Full PDF Opinion