Stepparent adoption; Termination of parental rights; MCL 710.51(6)(a); Ability to support or assist in supporting the child; $0 child-support order; Relevant two-year period; Clear & convincing evidence; Financial, medical & guardianship circumstances
The court held that the trial court erred by finding that respondent had the ability to support or assist in supporting the child for the full two-year period required by MCL 710.51(6)(a), and therefore termination of his parental rights for a stepparent adoption was improper. Respondent suffered a severe traumatic brain injury in 5/23, was placed under a full guardianship, required extensive rehabilitation and care, and was unable to continue working. His divorce judgment set child support at $0. Petitioners sought termination in 12/25. On appeal, the court explained that because a $0 support order “shall be treated in the same manner as if no support order has been entered,” the trial court was required to examine respondent’s actual ability to provide support. That inquiry required consideration of his “income, expenses, and general financial status and situation.” Working backward through the relevant two-year period, the court found evidence of an ability to contribute during the final 11 months through Social Security Disability benefits and some evidence of financial assets during part of 2024. But from 12/12/23 through early 4/24, “we detect virtually no evidence in the record that respondent had the ability to support or assist in supporting the child.” He had essentially no income, minimal funds, no control over his bank accounts, and remained dependent on family members. His medical condition was equally significant. He had a full guardian, could not make informed medical or financial decisions, and required substantial assistance with his own care. Indeed, “the record shows that respondent was unable to even care for himself during that period.” Because petitioners had to prove ability to support throughout a full two-year period by clear and convincing evidence, their failure under subsection (6)(a) made consideration of subsection (6)(b) unnecessary. Reversed.
Full PDF Opinion