e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86775
Opinion Date : 11/10/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/20/2026
Court : U.S. Court of Appeals Sixth Circuit
Case Name : In re: E. Palestine Train Derailment
Practice Area(s) : Litigation
Judge(s) : Thapar, Readler, and Hermandorfer
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Class-action settlement; Relief from judgment; FedRCivP 60(d)(3); Fraud on the court; Class counsel’s fiduciary duties; FedRCivP 23(g)(4); FedRCivP 60(b)(3); Fraud by an opposing party; Environmental testing; Confidential settlement terms; FedRCivP 60(b)(6); Extraordinary circumstances; Evidentiary hearing

Summary

The court held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in denying movants relief from the judgment approving the East Palestine train-derailment class settlement or in declining to conduct an evidentiary hearing on their Rule 60 motion. Norfolk Southern agreed to create a $600 million settlement fund after the derailment released hazardous chemicals into the environment. Class members could receive direct payments and could waive personal-injury claims for additional compensation. After the settlement took effect, 196 residents who signed personal-injury releases sought relief from the judgment, asserting that class counsel and Norfolk Southern concealed or misrepresented information concerning long-term exposure risks and environmental testing. On appeal, the court first rejected their fraud-on-the-court theory involving class counsel. As to counsel’s characterization of an expert video, the court concluded that “class counsel accurately represented the Carson video and didn’t need to say anything more. And without misrepresentations or duty-breaching omissions, there’s no fraud.” Claims involving another expert’s contrary opinions also failed because the district court knew of those opinions and counsel had no duty to disclose all underlying information. Further, “new post-settlement evidence, standing alone, doesn’t suggest class counsel lied to the court pre-settlement.” The Rule 60(b)(3) claims against Norfolk Southern fared no better. Its participation in environmental-testing decisions did not establish concealment, its decision to settle before completion of expert discovery was not misconduct, and the settlement openly disclosed the existence of a confidential supplemental agreement governing opt-out thresholds. The court noted that such confidentiality is common in class settlements and Norfolk Southern “had no duty to diverge from that well-trodden path.” Repackaging the same allegations under Rule 60(b)(6) did not establish extraordinary circumstances. Finally, because movants “made no evidentiary showing of fraud by class counsel or Norfolk Southern,” the district court acted within its broad discretion in deciding the motion without another hearing. Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion