Ineffective assistance of counsel; Failure to call a specific witness; Trial strategy; Denial of request for an evidentiary hearing; Failure to move to suppress evidence; Fourth Amendment; Tenants who have been ordered evicted; “Search”; Futile motion; Admission of defendant’s criminal record; Old Chief v United States; People v Swint; Harmless error; People v Lukity; Second Amendment as-applied challenge to the FIP statute (MCL 750.224f); People v Hughes; New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass’n, Inc v Bruen
The court held that defendant’s trial counsel was not ineffective and that Michigan’s FIP statute did not violate the Second Amendment as applied to him. While the trial court erred in admitting evidence of his prior conviction in spite of his stipulation, the court found that he was not entitled to relief under the harmless-error rule. Thus, it affirmed his FIP and felony-firearm convictions. He and his girlfriend were evicted from a rental home that they shared. The sheriff’s department carried out a district court’s eviction order. During that process, a “handgun was located just inside the door to the master bedroom that defendant shared with his girlfriend.” Police testimony indicated that it “was sitting out in the open on top of a shelf.” On appeal, he claimed that his trial counsel was ineffective for not calling the girlfriend as a witness and for not moving to suppress the gun. As to the former, the court found that the “prosecution’s evidence of possession was wholly circumstantial, so a reasonable trial strategy was simply to argue to the jury that the prosecution had not met its burden of proof, without the possible distraction of presenting the testimony of a defense witness with credibility problems—particularly when she would be the only defense witness and the last witness the jury would hear from.” As to the latter, the court concluded “that the deputies’ seizure of the weapon in this case was not the product of a ‘search’ within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment. Defendant had no reasonable expectation of privacy in the home because he had been lawfully evicted by court order and the officers’ entry was reasonably necessary to carry out” that order. They also “were not physically trespassing on a constitutionally protected area because they were acting pursuant to a lawful order that allowed them to enter the premises for purposes of carrying out the eviction.” Thus, a motion to suppress would have been futile. The court agreed with defendant that the trial court erred in admitting his criminal record but determined that he was not entitled to a new trial because he failed to show “that the error affected the verdict.” The evidence of his “constructive possession was circumstantial, but it was strong,” and the trial court gave a limiting jury instruction when the record was admitted. Finally, applying Bruen and Hughes, the court rejected defendant’s Second Amendment claim.
Full PDF Opinion