e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86779
Opinion Date : 11/10/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/20/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : People v. Lawrence
Practice Area(s) : Criminal Law
Judge(s) : Per Curiam - Patel, M.J. Kelly, and Garrett
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Expert testimony; MRE 702; PTSD, anxiety, & depression; Self-defense; People v Orlewicz; Ineffective assistance of counsel; Alleged juror misconduct; OV 7; MCL 777.37(1)(a); Excessive brutality

Summary

The court held that the trial court did not abuse its discretion by excluding defendant’s proposed psychological expert testimony, defendant failed to establish ineffective assistance of counsel, and 50 points were properly scored for OV 7 based on excessive brutality. He was convicted of second-degree murder after repeatedly striking the victim in the head and face until she died. Defendant claimed self-defense, testifying that the victim pointed a gun at him and maintained her grip on it while he struck her. He sought expert testimony that his PTSD, anxiety, depression, and trauma history affected how he perceived and responded to the alleged threat. On appeal, the court concluded that the testimony would not have assisted the jury. As in Orlewicz, the prosecution and defense presented “two competing and largely incompatible theories of what factually occurred.” Under the prosecution’s theory, defendant disarmed the victim and then beat her to death. Under his theory, she continued holding the gun while he defended himself. Thus, the expert’s proposed testimony “would have had no bearing on which scenario actually occurred.” The court explained that when there are two competing theories, testimony concerning a defendant’s psychological characteristics is not relevant unless it makes one version more or less probable. Defendant’s related ineffective assistance claims also failed because counsel made the substance of the expert argument clear, was not deficient for failing to cite every potentially applicable case, and any asserted failure to establish the expert’s qualifications caused no prejudice because the trial court did not exclude him on qualification grounds. Counsel likewise was not ineffective for failing to seek a mistrial based on alleged juror research where the juror testified under oath that she had not looked anything up. Finally, the evidence supported 50 points for OV 7. Defendant repeatedly struck the smaller victim in the face while she was pinned beneath him and crying, inflicting extensive head injuries. His conduct “involved excessive violence beyond the minimum required to commit the offense of second-degree murder.” Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion