Constitutional challenges under 42 USC § 1983 to Michigan’s 2021 Sex Offenders Registration Act (SORA 2021); Ex Post Facto Clause; People v Smith (MI); Mootness; Substantive due process; Equal protection; Offense-based tiers; Rational relationship to recidivism reduction; Limits on some registrants’ abilities to petition for removal from the SORA’s requirements; Procedural due process; The Michigan State Police’s (MSP) treatment of individuals with non-Michigan convictions; Mathews v Eldridge; Void for vagueness challenges to education, employment, & vehicle reporting obligations
[This appeal was from the ED-MI.] Holding that Michigan’s “SORA 2021 rationally relates to recidivism reduction[,]” the court rejected plaintiffs’ substantive due process and equal protection challenges to SORA 2021’s reliance on offense-based tiers. It also rejected their claim that allowing “tier I registrants—but not tier II or III registrants who remain offense-free—to petition for removal from the registry” violated the Equal Protection Clause. It further concluded that the education, employment, and vehicle reporting requirements were not facially vague. But as to the procedural due process challenge to the MSP’s treatment of individuals with non-Michigan convictions, the court agreed “with the district court that additional pre-deprivation procedures are required.” The court first addressed the grant of summary judgment for plaintiffs on their Ex Post Facto Clause claims. The court vacated and remanded those counts “for the district court to determine in the first instance whether” the Michigan Supreme Court’s decision in Smith mooted those claims. It did the same with Count VI, “plaintiffs’ retroactive-alteration-of-plea-agreements due-process claim.” But Smith did not “impact the other four counts at issue on appeal.” As to the reliance on offense-based tiers, plaintiffs’ expert’s report provided “some support for the notion that SORA 2021 reduces recidivism. This is sufficient to surmount the low bar set by rational-basis review.” And the support provided from studies of other states’ registries “for SORA 2021’s recidivism-reducing effects supplies a rational link to a nonpunitive purpose.” As to the restrictions on petitioning for removal, “Michigan could have rationally concluded that, even if tier I offenders’ and the subclass’s probabilities of reoffending converge over time, the subclass nevertheless poses a greater risk to the public.” As to plaintiffs’ claim about the treatment of juvenile registrants, “Michigan treats juvenile registrants better than other tier III registrants by allowing them to petition for removal from the registry after [25] years while generally barring adult tier III registrants from ever doing so.” But as to individuals convicted of non-Michigan offenses who are required to enroll in the registry, defendants did “not identify any interest arising from an extraordinary situation that renders post-deprivation process adequate.” Affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded.
Full PDF Opinion