Michigan Sex Offender Registration Act (SORA); In-person reporting requirements; Fourth Amendment seizure; Willman v Attorney Gen of United States; United States v Dionisio; Required court appearances; Malicious-prosecution seizure principles; Discrete seizure theory
[This appeal was from the ED-MI.] The court held that SORA’s in-person reporting requirements do not constitute seizures under the Fourth Amendment. Plaintiffs were individuals required to register under Michigan’s SORA. They challenged requirements that registrants appear in person for initial registration, periodic tier-based reporting, and reporting certain life changes, asserting that each required appearance constituted a discrete seizure because failure to comply could result in criminal penalties. On appeal, the court declined to rest solely on its prior decision in Willman, which involved federal sex-offender registration requirements, and independently concluded there was no seizure. It found Supreme Court precedent concerning grand-jury subpoenas instructive because compelled appearances differ from arrests or investigative stops. SORA reporting is not abrupt or “‘effected with force or the threat of it,’” and while sex-offender registration is stigmatizing, “the in-person reporting itself does not ‘result in’ that stigma.” The court also relied on precedent holding that being required to appear in court, without more, is not a Fourth Amendment seizure. A court summons and SORA reporting share the features plaintiffs emphasized because both compel an in-person appearance through the possibility of legal consequences for noncompliance. Yet SORA imposes even less restraint because registrants generally have flexibility within a prescribed period as to when they report. They also did not allege that once they arrived they could not leave and return later. Thus, a reasonable person would retain greater freedom to “terminate the encounter” than someone required to attend court at a fixed time. The court limited its holding to the challenged in-person requirements and did not decide whether additional liberty restrictions could amount to a seizure or whether a continuing-seizure theory is viable. Affirmed.
Full PDF Opinion