e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86810
Opinion Date : 11/16/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/18/2026
Court : U.S. Court of Appeals Sixth Circuit
Case Name : Ford Motor Co. v. InterMotive, Inc.
Practice Area(s) : Business Law Intellectual Property
Judge(s) : Clay, Kethledge, and Nalbandian
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Trade secret misappropriation under the Michigan Uniform Trade Secrets Act (MUTSA); Motion for judgment as a matter of law; Jury instructions on damages; Apportionment between protected & unprotected elements; MCL 445.1904; Burden-shifting; Sufficiency of the evidence as to damages; Unfair competition award under the Lanham Act; Reduction by the district court to prevent duplicative recovery; La Quinta Corp v Heartland Props LLC; Texas Advanced Optoelectronic Sols, Inc v Renesas Elecs Am, Inc (Fed Cir); Enhanced remedies under the Lanham Act; 15 USC § 1117(a); Trademark infringement; Motion for enhanced damages; Exclusion of expert testimony; Disgorgement remedy; Motion in limine; Exclusion of evidence & argument on an implied contract theory

Summary

[This appeal was from the ED-MI.] The court held that the district court did not err in denying plaintiff-Ford’s motion for judgment as a matter of law on defendant-InterMotive’s trade secret counterclaim under the MUTSA. It rejected Ford’s challenges to the jury instructions on trade secret misappropriation and to the sufficiency of InterMotive’s evidence on damages. The court upheld the district court’s (1) reduction of the jury’s damages award for unfair competition under the Lanham Act to prevent double or duplicative recovery, (2) denial of InterMotive’s motion for enhanced damages for trademark infringement, (3) exclusion of expert testimony related to disgorgement, and (4) grant of Ford’s motion in limine to exclude evidence and argument as to an implied contract theory. The parties had previously had a business relationship involving InterMotive’s designing an Upfitter Interface Module for Ford. On appeal, the court first declined to disturb the jury’s verdict for InterMotive on its trade secret claim, concluding the jury was entitled to credit the “testimony from InterMotive’s expert over other testimony and evidence in reaching its verdict.” As to the jury instructions on trade secret misappropriation, it found that “the district court’s burden-shifting approach and instructions to the jury were not erroneous[.]” It also agreed with the district court that the “‘jury could have reasonably found that Ford’s modules sales (and therefore module profits) were caused by Ford’s use of the trade secret, and that the stipulated number of Ford’s module sales represents the amount of additional module sales.’” As to the reduction of the unfair competition damages award, the court agreed “with the district court’s interpretation of La Quinta” and with its reliance on Texas Advanced, in which the Federal Circuit “determined that a jury verdict constituted an impermissible double recovery on very similar facts.” The court next found that InterMotive failed to show “that the district court applied the wrong law or otherwise abused its discretion in declining to enhance damages” for trademark infringement. It also upheld the exclusion of the expert testimony applying “a disgorgement of profits damages theory to InterMotive’s” contract breach claim. Finally, it held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in determining that both it and Ford “had not been put on adequate notice that InterMotive was asserting” an implied contract claim. Affirmed.

Full PDF Opinion