e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86821
Opinion Date : 11/17/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/18/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : In re Petition for Foreclosure of Certain Parcels
Practice Area(s) : Real Property Tax
Judge(s) : Riordan, M.J. Kelly, and Rick
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Tax-foreclosure surplus proceeds; General Property Tax Act (GPTA); MCL 211.78t(9); Scope of distribution order; Future claims under other legal theories; MCL 211.78t(11); Hathon v Michigan; Res judicata

Summary

Addressing an issue of first impression, the court held that MCL 211.78t(9) authorizes a trial court distributing tax-foreclosure surplus proceeds to bar future claims arising under the GPTA, but does not authorize it to bar claims arising under other legal theories. Claimant-Hamady, as trustee, sought surplus proceeds after property formerly owned by the trust was sold in a tax-foreclosure sale. The trial court ordered the State Treasurer to distribute $4,227.73 but also provided that all future claims concerning the foreclosure, sale, or proceeds were barred, including claims “under MCL 211.78t or any other legal theory.” On appeal, the court addressed an issue of first impression involving the final sentence of MCL 211.78t(9), which requires a distribution order to state that “any further claim by a claimant under this act relating to the foreclosed property is barred.” The court emphasized that although “any further claim” is broad, the statutory qualifier “under this act” is not. The trial court’s broader language rendered that limitation nugatory. Thus, “under MCL 211.78t(9), the trial court only was authorized to bar future claims arising ‘under this act,’ i.e., the GPTA.” This interpretation was consistent with decisions establishing MCL 211.78t as the exclusive mechanism for recovering surplus proceeds but recognizing that other claims, including challenges involving interest, attorney fees, or the constitutionality of the statutory process, may remain available after completion of that process. The court also rejected the State Treasurer’s reliance on res judicata. Because its application requires a fact-specific examination of an actual subsequent action, “its application is not something that a trial court might unilaterally decide with regard to hypothetical future claims.” The doctrine therefore did not authorize the trial court to prospectively extinguish claims under every conceivable legal theory. Reversed and remanded.

Full PDF Opinion