e-Journal Summary

e-Journal Number : 86822
Opinion Date : 11/17/2026
e-Journal Date : 11/18/2026
Court : Michigan Court of Appeals
Case Name : Northland Family Planning Ctr. v. Attorney Gen.
Practice Area(s) : Constitutional Law
Judge(s) : Borrello, Bazzi, and Lievense
Full PDF Opinion
Issues:

Constitutional right to reproductive freedom; Const 1963, art 1, § 28; MCL 333.17015 & MCL 333.17015a; Facial constitutional challenge; Strict scrutiny; Mandatory 24-hour waiting period; Uniform informed-consent requirements; Physician-only mandate; Coercion-to-abort screening; Nondiscrimination mandate under § 28(2); Appellate jurisdiction

Summary

The court held that Michigan’s mandatory 24-hour waiting period, uniform informed-consent requirements, and physician-only abortion mandate were unconstitutional, while the coercion-screening provisions do not burden or infringe that right under § 28(1). But further proceedings were required to determine whether those provisions discriminate in the protection or enforcement of reproductive freedom under § 28(2). Plaintiffs challenged provisions of MCL 333.17015 and 333.17015a after Michigan voters adopted the reproductive-freedom amendment. The court first concluded that the amendment expressly subjects burdens on that right to strict scrutiny. Once a statute imposes burdens, the State must establish a compelling interest, as constitutionally defined, and show the restriction is the least restrictive means of achieving it. As to the 24-hour waiting period, the record showed increased costs, delays, and other burdens without improved patient outcomes. The State “failed to identify any compelling empirical support” showing that the categorical delay advanced patient health in a way less restrictive alternatives could not. The uniform informed-consent provisions likewise failed because their “rigid, one-size-fits-all approach” displaced individualized clinical judgment and required information that could be irrelevant or detrimental in particular circumstances. The physician-only provision also impermissibly restricted access by excluding advanced practice clinicians even though the record supported their ability to safely provide early abortion care. The State failed to carry its strict-scrutiny burden as to each mandate. Next, the court found no error in the determination that coercion screening itself does not burden or infringe reproductive freedom because the provisions permit individualized screening and seek to protect voluntary decision-making. But it held that facial neutrality did not resolve § 28(2). Because the statutory scheme specifically addresses coercion to abort without similarly addressing coercion to become or remain pregnant, the court concluded that this asymmetry required examination of whether the law discriminates in protecting or enforcing the full spectrum of reproductive choices. Affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded.

Full PDF Opinion