St. Clair County Health Department (SCCHD) Regulation 25-01; De facto zoning ordinance; Michigan Zoning Enabling Act; County health department authority; Public Health Code; MCL 333.2435; Regulation of solar & energy facilities; 2023 PA 233; State-law preemption; Field & conflict preemption
The court held that SCCHD Regulation 25-01 was an invalid de facto zoning ordinance that the defendant-County Health Department lacked authority to enact and, alternatively, that the regulation was preempted by 2023 PA 233. Regulation 25-01 required Health Department authorization before construction of specified solar and energy facilities in rural areas and imposed detailed requirements concerning site plans, alternative locations, drainage, emergency response, decommissioning, noise, landscaping, and visual screening. On appeal, defendants argued that it was a public-health regulation rather than zoning. The court disagreed. A zoning ordinance regulates land and buildings according to areas or locations, and Regulation 25-01 did precisely that. Its requirements controlled “how the property can be used” and addressed matters such as facility layout, landscaping, alternative locations, and decommissioning. “These requirements and standards go to the heart of traditional zoning concerns.” The Health Department could not rely on its general authority under MCL 333.2435(d) to safeguard public health because the Public Health Code does not empower county health departments to impose broad land-use controls. Rather, the Legislature authorized them to advise appropriate local agencies on matters involving physical facilities. The court summarized that “when Regulation 25-01 looks and acts like a zoning ordinance, calling it something else does not make it so.” Because the Health Department was not a local unit authorized to zone, adoption of the regulation was ultra vires. The court further held that even if the Health Department possessed such authority, PA 233 preempted the regulation. State law established standards under which qualifying energy facilities do not pose an unreasonable threat to public health or safety, while Regulation 25-01 imposed additional and more restrictive requirements, including a lower noise limit and visual-screening requirements. In doing so, it “impermissibly attempts to prohibit what the statute permits.” Affirmed.
Full PDF Opinion