Acquiescence for the statutory period; Tacit agreement; Daley v Gruber
In an order in lieu of granting leave to appeal, the court reversed the Court of Appeals judgment (see eJournal # 85602 in the 4/30/26 edition) that ruled defendants’ acquiescence claim failed entirely. The court agreed with concurring Judge Trebilcock that a preponderance of the evidence showed that the parties’ immediate predecessors (S and B) “mutually understood, for more than 15 years, that an old ash tree served as the properties’ boundary line, such that the alleged encroachments fell entirely on [B’s] property. This tacit agreement for the statutory period means, by operation of the doctrine of acquiescence, that [B] acquired title to that portion of the disputed property to the old ash tree, which he then conveyed as part of his sale to defendants.” The court remanded the case to the trial court “for a determination of the exact acquiesced-to boundary line based on the location of the old ash tree and to reinstate judgment in favor of defendants based on that determination.”
Full PDF Opinion